Mayweather v. "Ducked" Fighters

Here's how I think these fights could have possibly gone: 135 (0-1) LOSS (UD) Mosley (1999-2000) v. Mayweather who fought Augustus at 135 140 (4-0) WIN (UD) Kosta Tzyu (2003-04) WIN (UD/TKO10) Ricky Hatton (2005) at 140 instead of Gatti WIN (UD) Miguel Cotto (2005) at 140 WIN (UD) Many Pacquiao (2005) lightweight Pac at 140--sounds interesting 147 (4-2) WIN (MD) Miguel Cotto (2006-2008) WIN (UD) Shane Mosley (2005-07) LOSS (MD/TKO10) Margarito (2005-08) LOSS (MD) Paul Williams (2007-10) WIN (UD) Manny Pacquiao (2008-10) WIN (TKO10) Amir Khan (2009-11) at 147 or ~144 pound catch-weight like Marquez 154 (3-6) LOSS (MD) Austin Trout (2012-present) LOSS (MD) Winky Wright (2005-2007) LOSS (SD) Vernon Forrest (2007) LOSS (UD) Paul Williams (2008-10) LOSS (SD) Sergio Martinez (2008-10) JMW version LOSS (SD) Sergio Martinez (10-present) MW version moving down WIN (UD) Shane Mosley (2006-08) WIN (UD) Fernando Vargas (2005-06) WIN (competitive UD) Erislandy Lara (2011-present) 160 (0-1) LOSS (TKO10) Sergio Martinez (2010-present) I have Mayweather winning most of these (11-10), but I believe many of these fights (both wins and losses) are too close to call.

This is not to argue who Mayweather ducked or why he didn't duck them. This really just a list of interesting fantasy match-ups that could have conceivably happened or that could still happen (#-present). Which five of these fights would you have liked to see the most? Mayweather v. 135 Mosley (1999-2000) v. Mayweather who fought Augustus at 135 140 Kosta Tzyu (2003-04) Ricky Hatton (2005) at 140 instead of Gatti Miguel Cotto (2005) at 140 Many Pacquiao (2005) lightweight Pac at 140--sounds interesting 147 Shane Mosley (2005-07) Margarito (2005-08) Paul Williams (2007-10) Manny Pacquiao (2008-10) Amir Khan (2009-11) at 147 or ~144 pound catch-weight like Marquez 154 Austin Trout (2012-present) Winky Wright (2005-2007) Vernon Forrest (2007) Paul Williams (2008-10) Sergio Martinez (2008-10) JMW version Sergio Martinez (10-present) MW version moving down Shane Mosley (2006-08) Fernando Vargas (2005-06) Erislandy Lara (2011-present) 160 Sergio Martinez (2010-present) I see a lot of losses in that list Lara, Martinez, Williams, Forest,Wright, Trout Pacquiao, Cotto 2005 version Mosley Steroid version before the test crap

Mayweather v. 135 Mosley (1999-2000) v. Mayweather who fought Augustus at 135 Probably loses, he was coming off a period of inactivity if I remember things correctly. 140 Kosta Tzyu (2003-04) Wins. Ricky Hatton (2005) at 140 instead of Gatti Destroys. Miguel Cotto (2005) at 140 Destroys. Many Pacquiao (2005) lightweight Pac at 140--sounds interesting Wins. 147 Shane Mosley (2005-07) Wins Margarito (2005-08) Wins Paul Williams (2007-10) Loss Manny Pacquiao (2008-10) Wins. Amir Khan (2009-11) at 147 or ~144 pound catch-weight like Marquez Destroys. 154 Austin Trout (2012-present) Unsure. Winky Wright (2005-2007) Wins. Vernon Forrest (2007) Wins. Paul Williams (2008-10) Loses. Sergio Martinez (2008-10) JMW version Unsure. Sergio Martinez (10-present) MW version moving down Wins. Shane Mosley (2006-08) Wins. Fernando Vargas (2005-06) Wins Erislandy Lara (2011-present) Wins. 160 Sergio Martinez (2010-present) Loses.

Mayweather WUDDA beat all of THEM but the thing is. He did not fight them :) so he still ducked them right during those time ? :D

How are these "ducked" fighters? Vargas? Winky? Lara? Trout? Hatton? Tszyu? Cotto at 140? Mosley 06-08? You realize those were Mosley's worst years and Mayweather had called him out for a fight in 2005? Khan!? Read the thread description... some of these guys are fighters people have claimed Mayweather ducked (I'm not really saying he ducked them hence the quotation marks in the thread title) the others are fantasy match-ups that could have happened and would have been interesting to see. What do you think?

How are these "ducked" fighters? Vargas? Winky? Lara? Trout? Hatton? Tszyu? Cotto at 140? Mosley 06-08? You realize those were Mosley's worst years and Mayweather had called him out for a fight in 2005? Khan!?

I alway thought he would have lost to the lightweight Mosley and a 160 Martinez, and Winky at 154, he would have also lost to Vernon Forrest and Margarito would have troubled him but still lose, I don't see the rest touching him. I forgot Vernon, that would have been a good style match-up.

I alway thought he would have lost to the lightweight Mosley and a 160 Martinez, and Winky at 154, he would have also lost to Vernon Forrest and Margarito would have troubled him but still lose, I don't see the rest touching him.

It would have been great to see Mayweather against everyone on that list in that exact time but as we know boxing also work on timing and the timing especially with all the earlier fights were off. Yeah, any random five of these fights (within context and time frame) would have been interesting to see...

So what the list about then? How many of these bouts Mayweather would have won, lost or been too close to call. Also noting which ones would have been the most competitive or interesting match-ups...

It would have been great to see Mayweather against everyone on that list in that exact time but as we know boxing also work on timing and the timing especially with all the earlier fights were off.

I added a poll...

So what the list about then?