Castillo v Floyd I "It's not the fight we saw"

Castillo intentionally targeted the shoulder over and over. Watch the fight and you'll see. He did damage to the Shoulder in the second round? Lol Yall have to stop making excuses! The guy was injured from the beginning of the fight, and complained as soon as soon as the fight started! If that part wasnt recorded, then you'd have an argument! Too bad he didnt make up the excuse after the fight!

So... a fighters record looks better than it is because he "robbed" the other guy. When hasn't this happened in boxing exactly?

Just looked in to see how the Pacquiao KO therapy was going for his fans. Coming along well, I see. Now we've established that Castillo was unlucky not to get the decision... again, I recommend talking about how Mayweather was rocked by DeMarcus Corley (another southpaw, for extra benefit) along with some anti-depressants and some counselling. Haha these *******s are gonna bring up the 2nd round in the Mosley fight next just watch.

Well Floyd does seem like the kind of fast paced mind to forget. All I know is that in the second round, he said he was injured. If he made the excuse after the fight youd have an argument. I can see if it was like alexander and bradley, but Floyd was injured all the way in the 2nd round. Then did the rematch to show it was no reason for him to lose the first fight! Castillo intentionally targeted the shoulder over and over. Watch the fight and you'll see.

Just looked in to see how the Pacquiao KO therapy was going for his fans. Coming along well, I see. Now we've established that Castillo was unlucky not to get the decision... again, I recommend talking about how Mayweather was rocked by DeMarcus Corley (another southpaw, for extra benefit) along with some anti-depressants and some counselling.

Yup, the poll shows how reasonable boxing fans scored it.

lol watch the fight. Floyd claimed it was his LEFT shoulder that was injured. Then he claimed it was his RIGHT shoulder on that TV show 'Soul Of A Champion.' http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=138145 Well Floyd does seem like the kind of fast paced mind to forget. All I know is that in the second round, he said he was injured. If he made the excuse after the fight youd have an argument. I can see if it was like alexander and bradley, but Floyd was injured all the way in the 2nd round. Then did the rematch to show it was no reason for him to lose the first fight!

The public census doesn't matter because the public aren't professional judges who judge bouts for a living. The professional judge census was and will always be, 116-111 Mayweather, 115-111 Mayweather and 115-111 Mayweather. Doesn't matter how much you Mexican fanboys cry or how many years pass, Jose Louis Castillo will ALWAYS go down as the guy who came up short. :alucard::bottle::alucard: Sorry to bust your balloon. Floyd has already come up short. 43-0 is good, but not even close to the numbers that describe true greatness. He'll need to double that win streak to get there. By my calculation, he'll be 75 years old.

Pactard Consolation General? He ded? He ded! 911! 911! He ded!!! http://i.imgur.com/AN8Px.jpg ahhhh ****.i almost flatlined:rofl:

I just watched the fight with my brother and I had Castillo winning 9-3 with 2 rounds that I thought could've gone eitherway. Even if I gave Floyd those rounds it would stil be a 7-5 win for Castillo

I see someone didnt actually read my comment nor watch the fight! Floyd complained about his shoulder from the beginning of the fight! The second round! He did not make up the excuse after the fight! Learn the game of boxing bro lol watch the fight. Floyd claimed it was his LEFT shoulder that was injured. Then he claimed it was his RIGHT shoulder on that TV show 'Soul Of A Champion.' http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=138145

When people are still talking about the only fight you "possibly" lost in your career, and it was 10 years ago, and you gave an immediate rematch but people still only can hate on the first fight, hell, you're a great fighter.

The public census will always be that majority of knowledgeable boxing fans will have Castillo winning their first bout. This poll has been created several times spanning multiple forums and every single time Castillo is voted to have won their first bout. The public census doesn't matter because the public aren't professional judges who judge bouts for a living. The professional judge census was and will always be, 116-111 Mayweather, 115-111 Mayweather and 115-111 Mayweather. Doesn't matter how much you Mexican fanboys cry or how many years pass, Jose Louis Castillo will ALWAYS go down as the guy who came up short. :alucard::bottle::alucard:

Just reviewed Jose Luis Castillo v Floyd Mayweather I. Lederman score card: 115-111 Castillo. Judges scorecards: 115-111 Floyd. Lampley: "It's not the fight we saw." I saw Castillo win rather easily. What fight did you see? Same. ^^^^^^^^^^

I had Castillo winning by a couple of rounds. I don't really think that could be argued with tbh. Floyd did figure out what went wrong, and came back to beat him in the rematch, though, so give him his dues for that.

What an ungrateful brat Floyd Jr is, Arum bought this title for him and look how he pay him back.:nono:

I see someone didnt actually read my comment nor watch the fight! Floyd complained about his shoulder from the beginning of the fight! The second round! He did not make up the excuse after the fight! Learn the game of boxing bro Last time I watched it, I had it a draw. For me, the interesting thing is that JLC is the only one who came close to solving the Mayweather puzzle. Even the re-match (which I haven't seen in a long time admittedly), he caused FMJ a lot of problems and it was only towards the end that Floyd pulled away. Castillo was one heck of a fighter. That is an interesting observation. The psychology that one must solve Floyd's puzzle to win. The key has always been to force Floyd to solve his competitor's puzzle. For some reason, nobody has ever tried that, except maybe JLC. Even Oscar got lured in and finally wore out and lost.

Oktay Urkal should have gotten the nod against Tsyzu, he was robbed imo

You know what? Nevermind..............

I started to respected Floyd because when everyone said he lost to Castillo, he proceed to rematch Castillo and won quite convincingly, But he move to 140 and up and started to pull ***** moves. Waiting for fighters to loose their prime to then fight them. Floyd wasn't expecting such a stiff competition in the first fight. Actually it was such a controversial fight that Floyd pretty much had no choice but to rematch. Bob Arum, as Floyd states was Floyd's boss, told Castillo that he was getting a rematch. It was stated in the post-fight interview.