Ok lets see your new p4p lists

1. Ward 2. Martinez 3. Mayweather 4. JMM 5. Donair 6. V. Klit 7. Pac 8. Bradley 9. Froch 10. Mares Future Top 10: Broner Gamboa However I wouldn't be surprised if Pac was taken from the P4P list entirely as he fought Mosley when Mosley was garbage. Technically lost to Bradley and KTFO vs JMM. The irony of it all was that 2 out of the three where not even WW's. I feel that #7 is being VERY generous to Pac.

Gamboa beat Salido and Salido is higher than Gamboa. Inactivity. But I'd understand if you had Gamboa ahead. Soon as he steps up next (Possibly Salgado?) and wins, he'll be in mine.

WARD IS #1 NO QUESTION floyd has done NOTHING! SHOT COTTO , CHEAP SHOT ORTIZ WHO LOST TO LOPEZ! i think he makes the list on skills alone but to be #1 is just a ridiculous statement WARD MARQUEZ MARTINEZ FLOYD MANNY DONAIR FROCH BRADLEY klitschko GUERERRO

1-Ward 2-Floyd 3-Marquez 4-Martinez 5-Donaire 6-Wlad 7-Bradley 8-Vitali 9-Froch 10-Mares u have bradley at 7 and no manny ? how does getting koed in a fight u where arguably wining knock u completely off the list ?

My list: 1. Mayweather 2. Martinez * 3. Marquez* 4. Ward* 5. Donaire 6. Pac 7. Wladimir 8. Bradley 9. Vitali 10. Mares *interchangeable

1. Mayweather 2. Ward 3. Marquez 4. Martinez 5. Donaire 6. Pac 7. Froch 8. Bradley 9. Mares 10. Alvarez No Heavweights Perfect list.

1. Floyd Mayweather 2. Juan Manuel Marquez 3. Andre Ward 4. Sergio Martinez 5. Wladimir Klitschko 6. Manny Pacquiao 7. Abner Mares 8. Guillermo Rigondeaux 9. Nonito Donaire 10. Yuriyorkis Gamboa

Just a question, how can you rank Bradley over Pacquiao? Last time I checked, official bad decisions weren't considered into head-to-head subjective comparisons, considering we have the fight to look at. cause he beat Manny and Manny was just layed out cold.

1. Floyd 2. Marquez 3. Ward 4. Donaire 5. Martinez 6. Bradley 7. Mares 8. Froch 9. PACQUIAO 10. Broner

1.Ward 2.Mayweather 3.Martinez 4.Marquez 5.Pacquiao 6.Donaire 7.Froch 8.Wladimir Klitschko 9.Bradley 10.Vitali Klitschko

im not spinning anything, he beat bradley and got robbed. you know it too. In that case, he lost to Marquez last November. In your words: You know it too.

1. Marquez 2.Mayweather 3.WArd 4.Martinez. 5.Pacquiao 6.Donaire 7.W.Klitscko 8.Bradley 9.Mares 10.Guerrero

1. Mayweather 2. Marquez 3. Ward 4. Martinez 5. Pacquiao 6. Wlad 7. Donaire 8. Froch 9. Broner 10. Canelo :bad:

1.Marquez 2.Donaire 3.Ward 4.Martinez 5.Floyd 6.Wlad 7.Pacquiao 8.Vitali 9.Viloria 10.Mares

1.Mayweather 2.Ward 3.Martinez 4.Marquez 5.Donaire 6.W Klitschko 7.Pacquiao

1. Mayweather 2. Ward 3. Marquez 4. Martinez 5. Donaire 6. Bradley 7. Pacquiao 8. W. Klitchsko 9. Froch 10. Broner Mayweather stays at 1 because there still is not anyone out there who can beat him.I put Marquez over Martinez because of Martinez' mishap at the end of the Chavez fight. I would have had pacman at #5 without the KO. Kind of early for Broner to be on the list but he took out the top lightweight with ease and looks pretty unbeatable to me. Plus I couldn't think of anyone else better to fill that last spot.

well he did lose to Bradley no matter how you spin it he lost and he was just knocked out cold and before that he aguably lost to Jmm yet again,sorry i cant rank him over fighters who have done nothing but win im not spinning anything, he beat bradley and got robbed. you know it too. how can you pretend he deserved to lose the decision to bradley then turn around and say he arguably lost to JMM in their third fight? if you are gonna stand by the judges decision even when its clearly incorrect atleast it should apply to all fights, not just the ones that fit your agenda. clearly you are the only one here trying to spin things. he was knocked out cold by JMM, but JMM is one of the very best fighters p4p. for the third time, just bcuz you cant beat a fighter in the top3 p4p doesnt mean you arent top 10. but i get it, to you not losing is more important than beating top fighters. if you have a bunch of garbage wins and an undefeated record thats more impressive than having a bunch of great wins if there is a loss mixed in there too. nobody should be fighting the best, just take easy pickings and point to the fact that they havent lost. i guess by your standards calzaghe is the goat?

My reason for Salido over Gamboa is that Juanma was a top10 p4p fighter when he got beat by Salido. Twice. In awesome fights. Salido was not a p4p guy when Gamboa beat him. And it was years ago. Salido was a very highly regarded fighter though when Gamboa beat him and is a very good win. But not as good as 2 wins over Juanma with the status he had imo. Gamboa is close to top10 list though. Viloria is a great pick for 8-10th spot.

still shocks me that no one thinks brian viloria is finally top ten p4p worthy......

How long till they change this? http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/view.php?pg=pound