If Pacquiao retires, who would you rate as the top 3 opponents of his career?

1.Barrera 2.Marquez 3.Morales Bonus: Cotto/Hatton This here...

His top 3 wins IMO; 1. Barrera 2. Marqeuz 2 (scored it for Marqeuz but could have gone either way) 3. Sasakul. His most competitive fights in which he won; 1. Marquez 2 Hard to say from now, Morales 2 maybe? Didn't really consider that too competitive. Not sure what I'd put third.

I'm assuming you mean who put up the best fight in his wins... 1. Marquez (1st fight) 2. Morales (2nd fight) 3. Cotto Yes, that's the idea. It's all about competitiveness against him, not resumes. Still, it's not just one fight. I mean tough overall like JMM in all their fights or Morales in the first two.

Marquez Barrera Morales Barrera got beaten the worst, but we cannot forget that he was pretty much near prime and was a top 3 guy in the p4p list.

I'm assuming you mean who put up the best fight in his wins... 1. Marquez (1st fight) 2. Morales (2nd fight) 3. Cotto

Let's get some more lists in here.

Accomplishments wise Oscar would be #1. :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: In what world does Oscar have a better resume than Marquez, Barrera or Morales?

Cotto dont count because of the CW and the fact that Manny wanted him first choice to fight again , Cotto said yes and Manny ducked the fight because of weight , which PROVES Manny knew the first CW weakened him ., because its the same fighter right , wrong and Manny knows it . I am referring to how the fights went. Cotto, catchweight or not, was very competitive during the early rounds. That's why I picked him for the third spot.

I think the first two choices are obvious, based on results and competitiveness. The third one is up for debate. Anyway, here's my list: 1. Márquez - He went 1-2-1 against Pacquiao (some would argue that he might have won, at least, two of the fights), won more rounds against him than anybody, and stopped him while Pacquiao was still considered a top 3 P4P fighter. 2. Morales - He went 1-2 against Pacquiao and was the only one, between 2005 and 2012, to hold a legit, clear win over him. Morales also gave a really good fight in the rematch although the third fight was disappointing. Still, Morales proved his worth and his 2005 win is still legendary. 3. Cotto - Okay, Cotto was dominated throughout the second half of the fight but the first six rounds were some of the most action packed of Pacquiao's career. I would say this is debatable, but I think Cotto was the toughest of the bigger guys that Pacquiao faced. Cotto won a few early rounds and outboxed him in spots. I know the third choice is not a sure thing, but the first two should be, more or less, consensus picks. Post yours. Cotto dont count because of the CW and the fact that Manny wanted him first choice to fight again , Cotto said yes and Manny ducked the fight because of weight , which PROVES Manny knew the first CW weakened him ., because its the same fighter right , wrong and Manny knows it .

Ok, this was a double post. Anyway, who are, to you, the ones that gave Pacquiao the toughest times? Select three.

I don't know but it seems like my thread has been misunderstood. I don't mean his best wins because of name recognition or the opponent's resume. What I mean is the three that performed the best and had good results against Pacquiao.

Well, the biggest wins he has on his resume are Barrera, Morales, & Marquez. Those four guys are the Fab-Four for the 2000 period.

Morales Barrera Oscar Pac is still 2-1-1 against JMM

1. Olympic 2. Style 3. Tests

Clottey, Margarita, Mosely

Gamblin' Drinkin' and Whorin' :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: I dunno man, I think those whores were past their prime.

I think the first two choices are obvious, based on results and competitiveness. The third one is up for debate. Anyway, here's my list: 1. Márquez - He went 1-2-1 against Pacquiao (some would argue that he might have won, at least, two of the fights), won more rounds against him than anybody, and stopped him while Pacquiao was still considered a top 3 P4P fighter. 2. Morales - He went 1-2 against Pacquiao and was the only one, between 2005 and 2012, to hold a legit, clear win over him. Morales also gave a really good fight in the rematch although the third fight was disappointing. Still, Morales proved his worth and his 2005 win is still legendary. 3. Cotto - Okay, Cotto was dominated throughout the second half of the fight but the first six rounds were some of the most action packed of Pacquiao's career. I would say this is debatable, but I think Cotto was the toughest of the bigger guys that Pacquiao faced. Cotto won a few early rounds and outboxed him in spots. I know the third choice is not a sure thing, but the first two should be, more or less, consensus picks. Post yours. This is off topic but I think pac's career started going down hill when he started rockin that Justin beiber haircut,, when he had the traditional Mexican buzz cut he was whooping ppl,,, manny get a haircut and come back and fight gay weather,,, props to Marquez, and no he's not on p.e.ds but yes he's on p.i.s.s Maybe they need to ban drinking urine before fights,, I bet there 1 million little Mexican kids who woke up this morning and had a big cup of pee. And no I'm not racist I'm puerto rican and Guatemalan for all the ppl who gonna say that I'm racist,,, honestly I like and respect both fighters,,,, we are seeing the end of an era ppl,,, pac's almost done cottos almost done Floyd's almost done, Marquez is almost done,, after this class of warriors leave I really don't See myself being that passionate about boxing anymore,,,, ppl enjoy your favorite fighter while there here and in there prime Cus it's hard to see them when they start to decline---- up next on the declining block is floyd money mayweather,, and I'm not hating it happens to all fighters

1. morales 2. marquez 3. barrera

1. Marquez 2. Singsurat 3. Torrecampo

I mean competitive wise, not resume wise. Barrera is a legend but I don't think he was that competitive against Pacquiao. I would say Margarito or Bradley were more competitive against him.