Marquez the greatest Mexican boxer ever?

Yes, he's the greatest.

Not the greatest but certainly up there with the elite.

Yes. Marquez is the best boxer Mexico has ever produced. People that say Sanchez and Chavez are greater are simply nostalgic. Sanchez didn't have enough time to prove everything that he was and Chavez was very popular, but is not the master technician that Marquez is. Marquez with this win has eclipsed JCC Sr.'s popularity anyhow. Marquez at 39 has knocked out a top 2 p4p fighter in devastating fashion. Something no Mexican in history has ever done. Yeah, but Chavez was ranked P4P # 1 when he was fighting. No fighter will ever be as popular in Mexico as Julio Cesar Chavez was. Marquez is one of the greatest but not the greatest Mexican fighter ever.

He's won titles in 4 weight classes, he didn't win a major title tonight. He's not the greatest Mexican ever, but he took a huge leap forward and close to it tonight, getting a stoppage win over a #2 P4P Pacquiao. It certainly puts him close to the Top 50 All-Time, if not inside of it now. pacquiao was still ranked number 1 by the ring he just shares the spot with floyd

eh I still put Morales ahead of him..

I thought Marquez beat John clearly, and he was up against the odds in that fight. Those deductions were bulls**t too, if my memory is correct.

what fight was you watching?John did not win more then 3 rounds. I felt John won with the point deductions. There was no robbery from what I recall.

Yes. Marquez is the best boxer Mexico has ever produced. People that say Sanchez and Chavez are greater are simply nostalgic. Sanchez didn't have enough time to prove everything that he was and Chavez was very popular, but is not the master technician that Marquez is. Marquez with this win has eclipsed JCC Sr.'s popularity anyhow. Marquez at 39 has knocked out a top 2 p4p fighter in devastating fashion. Something no Mexican in history has ever done.

Certainly one of the greatest. Dominated John? Don't think so. what fight was you watching?John did not win more then 3 rounds.

Certainly one of the greatest. Dominated John? Don't think so.

I would still rank Ricardo López, Chávez, and Salvador Sánchez ahead of him. I think Erik Morales might still be slightly ahead right now.

not the greatest but top ten easy.....

He's won titles in 4 weight classes, he didn't win a major title tonight. He's not the greatest Mexican ever, but he took a huge leap forward and close to it tonight, getting a stoppage win over a #2 P4P Pacquiao. It certainly puts him close to the Top 50 All-Time, if not inside of it now.