I just saw Cotto crack the BS Top 10 P4P list.

I love Cotto but he's not top 10 p4p.

Oh they're hyping him up for a Canelo fight already? Inb4 Canelo top 10 soon

I gave him three I think. No hate for Cotto, he tried hard and stuck to his task but was it a performance to lift him up the rankings? not for me. I got you man, and respect your opinion. i agree that wasn't enough to catapult him in the ranks, however, i'm glad he's getting his due. The man has fought the best names out there and is always willing to take on a challenge.

I think in this case he goes up by default, not because he had a big win this year. Cotto was borderline on several lists so if other fighters lose or don't look too good a borderline fighter could go up. That's his case, it seems.

I thought Cotto was competitive the whole fight. winning at least 4/5 rounds outta the 12. Also, when was the last time you saw any fighter give Floyd that much comp? Lastly, Mayweather was the one that stated he would fight Cotto at 154 lbs. I gave him three I think. No hate for Cotto, he tried hard and stuck to his task but was it a performance to lift him up the rankings? not for me.

Did he though? he won about 2/3 rounds and almost got stopped in the 12th plus FMJ had to step up to 154lbs. I thought Cotto was competitive the whole fight. winning at least 4/5 rounds outta the 12. Also, when was the last time you saw any fighter give Floyd that much comp? Lastly, Mayweather was the one that stated he would fight Cotto at 154 lbs.

Because he gave one of the best fighters of our era, a serious run for his money. :boxing: Did he though? he won about 2/3 rounds and almost got stopped in the 12th plus FMJ had to step up to 154lbs.

How do you lose then move up?? Because he gave one of the best fighters of our era, a serious run for his money. :boxing:

How do you lose then move up?? I guess bloodying mayweathers nose makes you p4p one of the best...lol. It was a close fight I think I gave him ... 3 rounds or so. >_>

How do you lose then move up?? cos these lists are based mostly on exposure.

How do you lose then move up??

Cotto is on many P4P lists. ESPN, SI, Yahoo and many others.

The Cotto creep strikes again it never fails :lol1:

He is not. That list shouldnt be based on resume. It should be based on current and recent achievements.

there take on the top 5 is as real as it gets although i dont agree with ward being topdog i can live with it

Cotto doesn't belong there, but like I've said in the other ridiculous thread... it's all opinion anyhow.

You do know BS is for Bullsh-t right? It's Bullsh-t's Top 10 P4P rankings. Manny Pacquiao #1 for a long time, even after controversially winning against Marquez, and controversially losing against Bradley, the guy stays untouched. Ward had to stop Dawson to finally get Pacquiao out of there. Kessler, Bika, Abraham, Froch > Clottey, Margarito, Mosley, De La Hoya. Ward should have been above Pacquiao since one year ago. Abner Mares should be in the top 20 P4P before Moreno. Well, it's Boxingscene but you can think whatever you want to think.

The ESPN a joke too they have Cotto over Froch Carl Froch 6-2 Jean Pascal Jermain Taylor Andre Dirrell Mikkel Kessler Arthur Abraham Glen Johnson Andre Ward Lucian Bute but he not in the top 10?

You do know BS is for Bullsh-t right? It's Bullsh-t's Top 10 P4P rankings. Manny Pacquiao #1 for a long time, even after controversially winning against Marquez, and controversially losing against Bradley, the guy stays untouched. Ward had to stop Dawson to finally get Pacquiao out of there. Kessler, Bika, Abraham, Froch > Clottey, Margarito, Mosley, De La Hoya. Ward should have been above Pacquiao since one year ago. Abner Mares should be in the top 20 P4P before Moreno.

Good Job Boxingscene! as they say real recognize real!! Best Boxing website in the world! Respect!!