I see a certain fanbase claiming its the same. So I have a few questions to set this debate straight.
How many times has Martinez competed at 168??
How many titles has Martinez held at 168??
Has Floyd ever competed at 154??
Has Floyd ever held titles at 154??
Why can't Floyd & Martinez meet at 154 to fight??
How does a certain fanbase claim that Martinez moving to 168 is the same as a 2 time champion at 154 (Floyd) fighting Martinez at 154??
Ok lets get this straight.
Floyd fought a past prime DLH at 154. DLH best weights were at 140 and 147, he was never good past 147. And then he fought Cotto at 154, again Cotto fought his entire career at or under 147. Cotto fought a completely destroyed and broken Margarito at 154 (after taking career ending beatings from Mosley and Pacquiao).
And you think Floyd fighting those over the hill fighters at their UNNATURAL weight is the same as Martinez moving to a weight class he has NEVER fought at, and fighting the best super middleweight and top 3 p4p fighter in his prime, Andre Ward?
Get real dude. You often have good posts but right now your Floyd fanboyism. is showing hard.
Oscar was good at 154. Anyway Floyd fought those guys in 5th weightclass, the equivalent of Martinez fighting light heavyweight champions.
At least we're in agreement that Floyd has been to a weight and fought 2 champions where he was under sized big time at the weight, and that Sergio has yet to do that and go to 168. Cool.
Ok lets get this straight.
Floyd fought a past prime DLH at 154. DLH best weights were at 140 and 147, he was never good past 147. And then he fought Cotto at 154, again Cotto fought his entire career at or under 147. Cotto fought a completely destroyed and broken Margarito at 154 (after taking career ending beatings from Mosley and Pacquiao).
And you think Floyd fighting those over the hill fighters at their UNNATURAL weight is the same as Martinez moving to a weight class he has NEVER fought at, and fighting the best super middleweight and top 3 p4p fighter in his prime, Andre Ward?
Get real dude. You often have good posts but right now your Floyd fanboyism. is showing hard.
You know what youre right. Hes conflicted. All jokes aside this makes perfect sense.
The fact that canelo may get $8 mil to fight floyd pisses BUsh off more than anything. He loathes the fact that Canelo is on HBO and he hasn't beaten anyone credible. The only thing that would piss him off more is if floyd fought JCC at 160 or if Broner got a floyd fight.
Part of Bush wants to see floyd lose. The remaining 90% wants to see Canelo get murked.
You know what youre right. Hes conflicted. All jokes aside this makes perfect sense.
I don't like to paint with a broad brush, but in this case if the glove fits~
I am sure there are some that don't fall into that category though and those people are fine in my book.
Part of Bush wants to see floyd lose. The remaining 90% wants to see Canelo get murked.
What do you mean how come? Because I dont have it.
I dont remember reading it. I think it was a 24/7 or some broadcast and this was before Martinez even came on the scene.
Alright, you coulda say that to begin with lol
Started at 147, now fighting at 160/ case closed
So he doesn't have to test himself further? and the fact that Floyd went out of his depth to 154 for challenges can get used against him?
Do you not see how broke that argument is~ you know what don't answer because I don't care what you think or have to say.
How come you never dropped an article/post, hell not even a hint to where I can find the info?
What do you mean how come? Because I dont have it.
I dont remember reading it. I think it was a 24/7 or some broadcast and this was before Martinez even came on the scene.
Floyd out his own mouth said he would not fight at 160. He said JMW is his limit.
How come you never dropped an article/video, hell not even a hint to where I can find the info?
Wait you mean these posters just really want to see floyd lose? I never noticed that.
I don't like to paint with a broad brush, but in this case if the glove fits~
I am sure there are some that don't fall into that category though and those people are fine in my book.
Floyd likes to fight the "best" and get paid well in the process. Martinez beating Canelo would prove he is a worthy option. Martinez/Canelo would do good #'s (more because of Canelo) and if Martinez can really get him good, then he'll gain some new fans. I hope his team is seeing what I'm seeing, they need to go for Canelo right away.
I have no issue with that, although with Sergio's injuries I don't think the timing will work out.
The bigger Martinez makes his star the more likely that fight is to come off, at whatever weight, no doubt about it.
Started at 147, now fighting at 160/ case closed
So shouldnt the case be closed on Floyd now who has fought at 5 weight classes?
I mean are we really saying hes ducking a guy who has fought his last 7 fights at 160 pounds?
That is the thing, Floyd will be around for a long time so it is only a matter of time until he loses and all these cats that are dying to see him get beat will see it, but most will completely miss the signs because they are so focused on Floyd not fighting the guy they want at the exact time and will get made to look stupid even when he loses, even though they are dying to predict his downfall~
And they like to run their mouth about people not knowing the deal, which is very laughable.
Wait you mean these posters just really want to see floyd lose? I never noticed that.
That is the thing, Floyd will be around for a long time so it is only a matter of time until he loses and all these cats that are dying to see him get beat will see it, but most will completely miss the signs because they are so focused on Floyd not fighting the guy they want at the exact time and will get made to look stupid even when he loses, even though they are dying to predict his downfall~
And they like to run their mouth about people not knowing the deal, which is very laughable.
True. Its just a matter of time. Just like Tyson.
IMO If Zab was a professional and not a stupid ass clown hanging at lil kim and jay z video shoots, he would have beat floyd's ass already.
Well Martinez just did big business, regardless of how the a side or b-side was so realistically now is his best chance to press for the fight.
Canelo probably does bring more though.
Generally speaking though Floyd does big business with anyone, so there is only so much leverage anyone has on him which is the problem with the Manny fight, Floyd can march to his own drummer and has/can still do great and while Manny can still outdo everyone else he can't out do Floyd.
Still Floyd isn't a 154 pounder he just sometimes fights there against select opposition~
Floyd likes to fight the "best" and get paid well in the process. Martinez beating Canelo would prove he is a worthy option. Martinez/Canelo would do good #'s (more because of Canelo) and if Martinez can really get him good, then he'll gain some new fans. I hope his team is seeing what I'm seeing, they need to go for Canelo right away. It's always good when a fighter says they were the first to beat or expose a rising star, it makes the win mean that much more if the fighter goes on to do big things. Cotto is also looking at Canelo, but he's caught up with Trout.
No you have only proven you are a hypocrite and that you don't understand what the word means~
Also that you can move goal post and make straw man arguments, when confronted with real debate you fold up shop and try to downplay those calling out your hypocritical garbage.
Martinez can compete with Ward if he wants to prove his greatness like Floyd did by going out of his element to challenge guys above him, to bad Martinez doesn't want to do that but I don't require that and there is plenty of work for him to do at 160 since that division is heating up but when the division was dry he was still hanging there so it figures.
Started at 147, now fighting at 160/ case closed
agree 100%. I'm sure if floyd was told the Cartel would kick in $50 mil cash he'd be in azteca getting his face bashed in by a 180 lb JCC. Especially if he starts to lose the $250k bets.
That is the thing, Floyd will be around for a long time so it is only a matter of time until he loses and all these cats that are dying to see him get beat will see it, but most will completely miss the signs because they are so focused on Floyd not fighting the guy they want at the exact time and will get made to look stupid even when he loses, even though they are dying to predict his downfall~
And they like to run their mouth about people not knowing the deal, which is very laughable.
See, this is what I don't get with you dudes. How am I a hypocrite if I do not believe Martinez can compete with Ward at 168. You can't give me any logic explanation as to why you think he can other than (he's a great fighter).
What's hypocritical is when a guy like you, say that Martinez should go to 168 & fight the best fighter in the world, then compare it to Floyd. As if Floyd has ever went up in weight & fought the best fighter.
Fighting Arthur Abraham for his strap is compatible to how Floyd has moved up in weight. Like I said, fighting Ward is a cop out that hypocrites like you conjure up bro.
If I was saying that Martinez beats Ward at 168, then make an excuse as to why he shouldn't fight him, kinda like what you're doing when you say Floyd beats Martinez then make excuses as to why he shouldn't fight him, then I'd be a hypocrite, just like you.
Do you believe Floyd can compete with Martinez? Or do you believe he will get pasted. People think you're a hypocrite because you don't want Martinez to fight Ward because in your mind you think Martinez will get a hiding, it is also assumed that you believe Martinez would spank Floyd yet that is a fight you're eager to see.
For me I wouldn't mind seeing Mayweather fight Martinez for the same reason I wouldn't mind seeing Martinez fight Ward. It is an opportunity for both fighters to overcome the odds.
Also when Mayweather fought De La Hoya at 154lb what other Jr Middleweight would you have him fight? When Mayweather fought Cotto at 154lb what Jr Middleweight would you have Mayweather fight? Lara? Trout?
13y ago
Serious question. How is Martinez/Floyd the same as Martinez/Ward? | BoxingScene Community