It is very close to me. The Toney that KOed Barkley had it all. He had speed, skill, offense, defense, power, stamina and of course his iron jaw. But Toney was so rarely in good shape and Hopkins was always well prepared. I give Hopkins the edge just as I gave Mayweather the edge over Toney for the same reason in a simular poll a few days ago.
Toney is more talented but Hopkins is more disciplined in and out of the ring. He always tries to win every minute of every round while Toney often gets Lazy and takes rounds off. I see Hopkins winning a close decision.