If GBP can get Cotto to fight Canelo which fight would sell more Canelo or Chavez ?

I thought the votes would be more even. But that PR vs Mexico sells big on Pay Per View. GBP needs to get Cotto On board or lose their date and the MGM to Top Rank.

Whether they were fought on separate days on on the same day, I say Cotto-Ginger outsells Chavez-Martinez. Same day would just mean by a smaller margin. Why on Earth would Miguel Cotto or Canelo even agree to something like competing with another PPV on the same day, anyway, for such a big fight? Anyway you slice it, they would both be taking a significant loss in revenue simply due to the fact there is another good matchup on the same day. If Cotto vs Canelo would sell 1 mil on a weekend by itself (just throwing out a random number), why on Earth would either one agree to potentially having the PPV #s go down a few hundred thousand b/c there is another fight on at the same time? It would make zero financial sense, especially in the case of Cotto.

No matter how much trash talking that is occurring with Martinez/Chavez, the old Mexico vs Puerto Rico will always sell BIG!!!

Where have they gone btw? They're literally nonexistent. I don't know if this is a "for the time being" type of thing but for now they're gone. He lost to all the top dogs in the sport. Chavez-Martinez still outsells this fight. Cotto is not fighting and doesn't even have a fight scheduled. Why the hell would his fans still be flooding the site. You guys are like women, if you put it in you scream and if you take it out you cry. If they talk too much about him they are annoying and when they don't talk about him they dissappeared running away from boxing. Cotto vs Canelo, PR vs Mexico will sell any day especially with two known fighters. If you know anything about boxing this is a no brainer.

Cotto vs Canelo sells more...in these Puerto Rico-Mexico wars money comes second to their pride...

Cotto's fans are all gone, they were bandwagoners for the most part. Canelo can pull his own but he's still the smaller draw in comparison to Chavez Jr. Keep in mind TS is presuming they both take place on the same night. Nah bruh! Cotto fans are not all gone...

Canelo-Cotto by a wide margin. I just don't see this actually happening right now though. If this were a legit possibility I feel like they would have made this fight first instead of the other 3 options they tried. All 3 while good fights that I was excited to see were risky fights against guys without a lot of name value. Canelo-Cotto is a risky fight, but the reward is there for Canelo as well. Beating Cotto would make him a legit star. Paul Williams was my favorite fighters ever, and I'll always believe he would have beaten Cotto, but that doesn't change the fact that outside of hardcore fans he wouldn't gain as much for beating him as he would Cotto.

Cotto giving Canelo a beating will sell more that steroid JR vs Martinez. there sure are a bunch of JR and Canelo nut huggers and they call us Cotto fan boys. Idiots. :lol1:.........

I will be taking bets that Chavez-Martinez does more PPV buys than Canelo-X does if they are on the same day If it's Cotto (long shot) I got 5 billion that says otherwise. Other than that depending on the card, it may be close. Neither guy is or has been a big PPV attraction, but the fight will sell good (500k)

Canelo vs Cotto easy...not even close

Cotto giving Canelo a beating will sell more that steroid JR vs Martinez. there sure are a bunch of JR and Canelo nut huggers and they call us Cotto fan boys. Idiots.

Chavez-Martinez outsells everything except ginger-Floyd.

Canelo v Cotto...and it wouldn't even be close.

I always wanted to know who is the more popular fighter among mexicans Canelo or Chavez Jr?

Canelo is too green for Cotto. GBP will not sacrifice their young cash cow to the bull. Shaefer isn't stupid enough to do that just to one up Top Rank. Cotto just outclasses Canelo in every way possible. Regardless there is no way Jr. can outsell Cotto. Even at this point.

I voted for the wrong option, I thought the thread said which fight would I rather see. Obviously Canelo vs Cotto would outsell chavez vs martinez by a huge amount

Cotto Vs Canelo would obviously sell more. This isn't even debatable. I would very much like to see this fight.

I'm also a life time member of the Cotto Cartel! Cotto vs Canelo will generate the much larger PPV numbers. By far! I'm ready to lay all my eBillions on this fight. Miguel will pop Canelo's cherry and send him crying to mama on queer street with his panties down. War Cotto!

I am a solid member of the Cotto Cartel and a shameless mfkn gringo. However... Canelo is from Guadalajara, second greatest Mexican city. Been there done that. Cotto should just step up and clean out everything from 140-154. I'll take Cotto over fuggin che (boludo) Martinez. Pelotudo... I'll take Cotto over Canelo I'll take Cotto over Angulo,Kirkland,etc etc... no mamen...

I'd personally rather see Chavez Martinez .... it'll be closer than the beating Canelo will give Cotto over 12 rounds