He somehow beat Pac, Floyd, and then finished his career by beating Amir Khan to retire undefeated. Would you rate him above Floyd and Manny? Or would you see it as a Joe Calzaghe type of situation where he just caught two legends (BHop and Roy in Joe's case) at the downside of their careers?
After dominating 140 then beating the 2 pfp superstars & Khan for good measure?? That deserves a serious atg boost, serious.
Yes, he would essentially have cleaned out both the 140 and 147 lbs divisions. Not much more you could ask from him than that.