Froch (tonights version) vs Calzaghe

I meant to vote for Calzaghe but pick Froch by accident. Calzaghe wins head to head. But no doubt Froch has the better resume by a mile. By a mile? Hell you would think that Froch just knocked out Sugar Ray Robinson. Froch deserves the utmost respect for fighting and being competitive with everybody. Tough dude for sure. He did however lose to Kessler, who Calzghe beat easily, and although he has some solid wins on his resume, none are as good as a win over B-Hop, even though Bernard was old. I'll concede that overall his competition has been better, no doubt, but "by a mile"? Not so sure.

I meant to vote for Calzaghe but pick Froch by accident. Calzaghe wins head to head. But no doubt Froch has the better resume by a mile.

Calzaghe was better than Froch but he would cut off both of his testicles with a rusty knife to have Froch's resume. Calzaghe would have beaten Ward, I don't see anyone else doing it.

Calzaghe definately. He was quick, active, had decent defence, had good footwork and had a SOLID chin...if Bute had a good chin he should implement Calzaghes style when he goes back into training but he can't take solid shots well, so he should get a real jab tonight it sucked and when the other fighter gets close and lands shots tie him up straight away, jab and move seriously as soon as he got hit tonight he did not do ANYTHING....apart from one point where he landed some decent shots but they didn't seem to affect Froch at all whereas Bute was reacting negatively to every shot that hit him.

I think Froch pushes him to his very limit but Calzaghe's superior workrate and handspeed gets him a close decision imo.

calzaghe is all bad for froch's style. Froch would probably make it interesting for the first 4-5 rounds but calzaghe would adjust and get that decision clean. Well said by someone who ain't Calzaghe's biggest fan :lol1:

This always seem to happen after a good impressive victory. I don't think Froch would beat Calzaghe. I think he's too fast and smart and would outbox Froch.. definitely not get into trading shot for shot. It would be a fun fight though.

I love Froch but Joe wins fairly comfortably. Froch gives him a couple of worrying moments but for the most part Calzaghe remains untouchable. 118-110ish UD.

Calzaghe was just better than Froch skill wise, I think people who pick Froch in this match up are fooling themselves. Froch gets kudos for fighting everyone though.