Donaire not a P4P

Is Donaire a hype job? I was not impressed by him this past Saturday and I don’t think he deserves to be in the P4P list.. To me he hasnt proved anything... Let me know your thoughts ?? :lol1: you let Larry Merchant pick your brain lol...Flash is legit...don't let that bs Merchant was saying mess with your head.....dude can rumble....he's gonna be at the top for a long time!!

he's a P4P fighter but he should definitely be lower than Marquez.... I agree with NATAS list

yeah I think Ward should be bumped up to the top 5 and donaire should be at the bottom 5 somewhere. Should look something like this imo: 1. Floyd 2. Manny 3. Marquez 4. Ward 5. Martinez I don't know what to say about klitschko. I have no real opinion if he's on the list or not. Some people don't include heavyweights on their list, others do. Nice list.

the thing is i've seen both of those guys fight and find it very hard to believe that either could be rated particularly highly at all. especially vic. I'm pretty sure Vic wasn't top 10 at the time, he only got ranked post Donaire for his junior bantam unification and beatdown of Arce. Which is what carried Donaire into the p4p list, but he has since justified it. Montiel was ranked for beating Hasegawa and being a 3 weight champ, but wasn't an established bantam otherwise.

this is what happens when you dont follow boxing. the thing is i've seen both of those guys fight and find it very hard to believe that either could be rated particularly highly at all. especially vic.

I find it funny that people bring up that Darchinyan and Montiel were Top 10 P4P, which are two very good wins at the time, but then find a way to discredit that Corrales was #5 P4P, Hatton #8 P4P, Mosley #9 P4P, and Marquez #2 P4P with Mayweather. NSB is like the poster child for double standards with certain guys. hatton was a career 140 pounder who floyd fought at 147 when the previous fight before that it was quite clear hatton did not belong at 147 when above average contender was rocking him left and right. Mosley was 38 years old a couple of months shy of his 39th bday and coming off almost a year and a half of inactivity when he almost KTFO floyd. Marquez was a career featherweight coming off 3 brutal wars vs pac, diaz, and casa when floyd cheated him on the scales at welterweight. Corrales how fu k king long ago was that? not to mention all the drama he was suffering out of the ring. Now compare that to darchinyan who was undefeated, in his prime, top 10 p4p who was knocking everybody's heads off and montiel top 10, coming off 4 straight tko/ko victories including eveyrbodys flavor of of the month darling hozumi hasegawa when Donaire knocked them both the fu kkk out. :dunce: :spankme: nice try. flomo.

I find it funny that people bring up that Darchinyan and Montiel were Top 10 P4P, which are two very good wins at the time, but then find a way to discredit that Corrales was #5 P4P, Hatton #8 P4P, Mosley #9 P4P, and Marquez #2 P4P with Mayweather. NSB is like the poster child for double standards with certain guys.

W O W. how'd they manage that?! can i be pound for pound too? where do i buy the membership? I heard you have to have a walmart plus card this is what happens when you dont follow boxing.

W O W. how'd they manage that?! can i be pound for pound too? where do i buy the membership? I heard you have to have a walmart plus card

Vic & Montiel were both ranked top 10 pound 4 pound. W O W. how'd they manage that?! can i be pound for pound too? where do i buy the membership?

Donaire is now a four division champion and has two spectacular ko victories over (1)two top 10 p4p fighters in the whole sport in two different divisions. Just take a good look at the current top 10 p4p list, Other than floyd, manny, and marquez, Donaire's resume sh*ts on anybody else on the top 10 p4p in the whole sport. (2)And he's just getting started. (1) WHO are these two exactly? (2) well you obviously agree that he's gonna avoid rigo then.

Is Donaire a hype job? I was not impressed by him this past Saturday and I don’t think he deserves to be in the P4P list.. To me he hasnt proved anything... Let me know your thoughts ?? Donaire is now a four division champion and has two spectacular ko victories over two top 10 p4p fighters in the whole sport in two different divisions. Just take a good look at the current top 10 p4p list, Other than floyd, manny, and marquez, Donaire's resume sh*ts on anybody else on the top 10 p4p in the whole sport. And he's just getting started.

wtf does he have to do to get your "approval"??? the trend nowadays is if a fighter doesnt look good 1 time in over 6 years or something then he's slipping, or he doesnt deserve to be rank as p4p?? shiits funny how things work on here.. SECOND time in 4 MONTHS

why? You think top rank and Gbp gonna make up for this fight? Who said I don't think he has advantage now at 118? ok whatever...go on with what you think.

No. Mares should fight Moreno. I got Moreno in that fight, but it'd be competitive. Than, win or lose, unless the deicision was controversial or something, he should move up to 122.This what I would like to see. Mares v Nonito won't happen till arum gone. I think Moreno slick enough to cause major problems

so you already know mares will have more power and skills at 122 but did not have such advantage at 118? the **** is he doing at 118 then, huh? mares should move up immediately.why? You think top rank and Gbp gonna make up for this fight? Who said I don't think he has advantage now at 118?

so you already know mares will have more power and skills at 122 but did not have such advantage at 118? the **** is he doing at 118 then, huh? mares should move up immediately. No. Mares should fight Moreno. I got Moreno in that fight, but it'd be competitive. Than, win or lose, unless the deicision was controversial or something, he should move up to 122.

Like I said earlier that's fine for you to think that. When/if they fight we will see. I dont think he has more skills or power at this weight. He looked sluggish, tired fast, and didn't have the same pop. Speed ok but mares isn't as fast but he isn't a turtle in there. I don't see anything in doNaire arsenal that can beat mares but to each his own. But the subject here is I personally think he's good may be great one day but for now he is not on my P4P list but he is close so you already know mares will have more power and skills at 122 but did not have such advantage at 118? the **** is he doing at 118 then, huh? mares should move up immediately.

Mares is your typical Mexican fighter relentless come forward fighter. Mares can also box, but he doesn't have Donaire's boxing skills. Like Pac, Donaire eats these type of fighters for breakfast but in a different way. Mares is tailor made for Donaire the same way Arce is, which is why Arum will make Arce-Donaire next.arum will make donaire v arce cause they both top rank. What does PAC have to do with Nonito?

Donaire beats Mares in my book, but we'll never see it because of the promoters. If Vazquez could tag Donaire at times though, I think Abner could make a good fight with Nonito.