Prime Ricardo Mayorga vs Marcos Maidana

Mayorga,,, maidana and lucas are just wanna be mayorga fighters,,, Mayorga had much better power and chin, plus was in with the absolute best of his era six heads twice forrest twice spinks tito oscar vargas shane cotto

We have yet to see Maidana at 147 but I would still go with MAyorga. And It would be entertaining as hell. We've seen him at 147 a few times already buddy. I don't think Maidana would honestly stand a chance against prime Mayorga. It would be an 8th Round TKO.

Hmmm maidana would be considerably smaller, correct me if I'm wrong but didn't mayorga fight at 160 before? he'd have the bigger shots and could walk through just about anything (before he was cracked eventually) so i would have to go with mayorga but it wouldn't be easy. mayorga is beatable lol.

I still think Mayorga walks through him, anybody think different after Saturday?

Prime Mayorga was a beast. Mayorga would stop Maidana and i think he would do it early.

Mayorga wins a close sd in a war!

Prime Richardo was not only a tremendous puncher but pretty fast actually at 147, in the Forrest fight he looked much better than Maidana has in any fight. I see this as a total mismatch where Maidana gets whipped out early. ^^^ THIS.. Prime Mayorga was bigger, faster, harder punching and had a better chin.

mayorga would win easily.....

We have yet to see Maidana at 147 but I would still go with MAyorga. And It would be entertaining as hell.

I'd have to go with prime Ricardo. I can't see Maidana hurting him. We're talking about a guy who ate shots from a prime Vernon Forrest like they were M&Ms. Not to mention taking the shots Tito and Shane (who were past prime, but still tremendous punchers) put on him for as long as he did.