has roach training past its prime?

his fighters are actually facing real opponets

I hate that this is how the game is today. One loss and you're garbage. IMO Roach is a damn good trainer but he is overrated. I bet 99% of this board doesn't know what it takes to train a fighter and what to tell a fighter during a fight. They think it's easy but it isn't. The problem I had with him in the Khan fight is that he didn't seem to be telling him anything. Still won criticise Roach too much, Khan did win the fight imo.

When you guys are going to realize that Parkinson affects more than speech and nerve system. They cant think straight. His brain doesnt work the same way. IMO, he should retire. He shouldnt been training and taking all stress that is not helping him a bit.

I'm not ready to say that these fighter's losses are a reflection of Roach's coaching just yet, but I did notice that his instructions between round were particularly garbled last night. Hope he's in ok health.

He's never been that good to begin with. Just listen to his so called instructions in between rounds. Horrible just horrible.

I completely disagree with this post. Roach took Khan in after he was KO'd by Prescott. Even before Khan was KO'd by Prescott, I think he was dropped a few times. Fact of the matter is, Roach improved Khan's game a lot, regardless of the loss last night. Roach has done the same for Manny and a few other fighters. In fact, Roach was part of Mayweather's only SD win in his entire career. To say Roach is crap because one of his fighters lost a SD isn't the smartest thing to say.I hate that this is how the game is today. One loss and you're garbage. IMO Roach is a damn good trainer but he is overrated. I bet 99% of this board doesn't know what it takes to train a fighter and what to tell a fighter during a fight. They think it's easy but it isn't.

roach was always a good match maker and a terrible coach take his fighters into deep water and he'll drown with them.