How can anyone say Martinez is better than Donaire

Right now. I rate Donaire higher base on the last 4 fights for both fighters. Donaire resume seems to be better now. Would have love to see him fight against Moreno as Donaire SEEMS to going into fight not busy enough but looking to land the big left hook.

speaking of Williams Donaire is what PW was at 147 a freak at that weightclass with a huge size advantage over his opponents Get outta here! Don't compare Paul ****ing Williams to Donaire. It's like comparing Matthew Hatton with Manny Pacquiao.

P4P Donaire is obviously better then Sergio. You could definitely make a case for Donaire being #1 even. Sergio on the other hand, is definitely not top3 IMO.

speaking of Williams Donaire is what PW was at 147 a freak at that weightclass with a huge size advantage over his opponents not true, pwill towers above anyone when he was at welter including margarito. donaire is just as tall as yohnny perez and an inch shorter than anselmo moreno.

if anything that works against Martinez dumbass it means he wasn't in shape so by your logic did Hatton have a size advantage over Mayweather at 147? speaking of Williams Donaire is what PW was at 147 a freak at that weightclass with a huge size advantage over his opponents Yes Hatton did , he was 153 and Floyd was 152 .

IMO, Nonito is the #2 P4P guy doing it right now. Don't see an argument for Sergio being ranked higher than him.

they can't

also, if we talking about SIZE ADVANTAGE - how about Martinez weighing 176 to Williams 162 @ 30 days out?!?! To me that EVINCES A HUGE natural size advantage. if anything that works against Martinez dumbass it means he wasn't in shape so by your logic did Hatton have a size advantage over Mayweather at 147? speaking of Williams Donaire is what PW was at 147 a freak at that weightclass with a huge size advantage over his opponents

Marquez #2 Pound 4 Pound, Montiel or Martinez #3, Floyd #5, but those 1st 4 change on a monthly basis.

I think we'll see what Donaire is really made of when he stops cutting a lot of weight and moves up to featherweight. Both guys have those highlight reel KO's under their belt, they just need more career-defining fights.

if Sergio Martinez fought Nonito Donaire, Sergio would likely win. No hypothetical rankings, no pound for pound criteria to estimate who is better. Sergio defeats Donaire.

Donaire with his size advantage is beating up on smaller guys don't know how he makes 118 he should have been at 126 by now He weighed less than Montiel on fight night. Size isn't the reason he's so good. It's easy to forget about Donaire because he's done such a terrible job following up his biggest wins. He's better than Martinez, but Martinez is winning more often and staying relevant.

Donaire with his size advantage is beating up on smaller guys don't know how he makes 118 he should have been at 126 by now

Yep, whoever doesn´t look like a midget standing next to him. then the commisions should change weighclasses to heightcalsses then and let guys like david tua and sergio martinez fight.....:grumpy:

i think you mean height not size......coz if youre talking about size then its inaccurate , coz montiel was bigger than him when they fought and still got destroyed.... Yep, whoever doesn´t look like a midget standing next to him.

We have yet to see what Donaire can do against boxers of his size. i think you mean height not size......coz if youre talking about size then its inaccurate , coz montiel was bigger than him when they fought and still got destroyed....

We have yet to see what Donaire can do against boxers of his size.

Matter of opinion I guess. I rate Donaire higher than Martinez but others would disagree.

he aint...sergio's overrated @ss aint really all that as evident when he struggled and got busted up vs a bum...... but since he had a couple of good wins (pwill, pavlik) and to get with the progaram with the p4p list, i still have him at # 4 behind pac , nonito and floyd....

It's peoples opinions. Simple. Sport is a game of opinions; without them it would be pretty boring. I haven't seen enough of Donaire though to have a real opinion on him yet though; but he does look class from the highlights I have seen.