I see alot of people saying victor was not any good or not even top 10 at 140
but what are you forgetting is that sometimes the weight you start off at isnt your best. You try to go lower to have advantages on your opp being the bigger stronger guy but if you go to low your body doesnt react well. you may keep power but lose some things in the process like ability to take a shot ...ability to have stamina for 12 rounds and i will give examples
Amir Khan at 135 was moving along well intill he fought Prescott..i dont think it was so much that Prescott is a better fighter then Khan..its that at that weight he couldnt absorb a heavy shot..we see now that at 140 hes body is still filling out and hes able to take a punch much better(as we seen in Madiana fight)
Miguel Cotto at 140 was moving along great intill he met the likes of Ricardo Torres who dropped him a couple times in that fight and Chop Chop who had him hurt bad.hes body said its time to move up and had his best fights at 147 Zab heavy puncher..Shane Heavy puncher ..and lasted almost 12 rounds in a war with margo and didnt go down intill the later rounds
Now to Victor..Hes 23-24 years old...2005 he made his 140 debut which is 6 years ago making him around 18 years old...he last fought at 140 in the end of 2010..now your body from 18-24 years old starts to fill out alot..he couldnt make that weight anymore..he didnt have the stamina nor the ability to take a shot as he does now as we saw in berto fight..he looked much stronger and was working the whole 12 rounds..but before you say the man was nogood and will never be nothing give him a chance to pan out in 147
this doesnt go for everyone just making a few examples that if you start off in a weight class and you go too low your body will let you know
That's the thing, I feel that a lot of fighters don't know when they're pushing themselves too far, to them it's probably normal but in reality it's not. That might have been the case with Victor Ortiz here and why we saw a much more energized Victor at 147.
It all depends where you start.
if you start pro boxing at 15 you will gain like 20-30lb at the very minimum by the age of 30 (If you are properly trained)
If you start Pro Boxing at age 30 you will remain pretty much the same weight class.
If you start amateur at 8 your weight will go from very low to very high and you will stop growing according to your gene's and muscle mass.
Thats why I dont believe the Pactard BS about him juicing.
Pinoy land dont have "Amateurs". Kids just start boxing, and only a retard will think that a 16 year old kid is going to remain the same weight after 14 years. Once you start fighting and aging you earn more money for food/supplements that you couldn't afford when you were just starting out.
I guess only the retarded Flomo's think that a 16 year old kid starting boxing with no Amateur experience and poor broke and hungry is going to remain the same weight as he goes thru puberty and starts having money for proper food / training.
Your contention depends on how old the guy is and when he physically stopped growing. There are also many fighters who begin at higer weights and, as their bodies become more acclimatized to training and weight loss they gradually reduce the weight they fight at until an optimum weight is reached.
Lots of guys began as Lt.heavy and ended up as 168 or 260 lbers' and so on. The average guy, even the fittest, carries quite a bit of weight which is useless for fighting purposes, and gets to lose it when seriously training to make a desired weight.
Sorry for the slip, mean obviously, 160 lb'ers.
Well for 1, the weight you start at usually isn't your best weight because the average boxer starts lower & matures into a weight class or 2 heavier.
Your contention depends on how old the guy is and when he physically stopped growing. There are also many fighters who begin at higer weights and, as their bodies become more acclimatized to training and weight loss they gradually reduce the weight they fight at until an optimum weight is reached.
Lots of guys began as Lt.heavy and ended up as 168 or 260 lbers' and so on. The average guy, even the fittest, carries quite a bit of weight which is useless for fighting purposes, and gets to lose it when seriously training to make a desired weight.
I agree and even though Ortiz just recently said he never had trouble getting to 140, losing weight easily doesn't always equate with being 100% (and maybe not knowing your not). I suppose any athlete could lose weight, it's not impossible, it's a matter of, does it benefit me, when you account for body fat/muscle mass to ones bone structure.
On top of that, just for basics, we all grow. It was inevitable for a young man, such as Ortiz, to move up and perhaps perform better (although he has to prove this with more fights) in a division where he may not need to rob himself of muscle mass. Experience is always good too. :boxing:
most of the time fighters drop way too much weight to be dominant in their prospected weight classes, then move up because they can't make that weight anymore, proving that they didn't belong there in the first place......
that is a common happening in boxing and all combat sports because of the 24 hours between the weigh in and the fight, it's a totally different beast with the weigh in on the same day as the fight..... 24 hour rest between weigh in and the fight allows for such gross weight dropping, which is not good and also allows fighters to fight in weigh classes they shouldn't otherwise be fighting in.
now with that being said, the same adjustment goes the other way around, which is by far the harder of the two.....
and that is to realize that you'd be better at a lower weight, starting off too heavy then dropping down a weight class or two, then staying there for the majority of your career... doing that is harder than moving up in weight, unless you're one of those guys that fights at his walking around weight.
hopkins is the best example of this, making the adjustment, dropping down and staying there....... the key word there is STAYING there. because it's harder to keep the weight off of you when you're getting older.
your muscles are more dense, your innards are always growing, your metabolism slows down, making it harder to keep weight and fat off, getting older and maintaining your weight is far harder than dropping weight far beyond what is natural for your body then to be forced to go up in weight because the body can't handle and make it anymore.......
bottom line is this, there is a perfect weight class for every fighter, whether their best weight class is their natural one or a manipulated one, in either case, if the fighter can't fight he will be exposed, in any weight class.
This.
Thread went well.
i put this thread up because i seen alot of ppl saying that ortiz wasnt nothing at 140lbs and had to put examples up to have them see the light..that was th epoint of this thread and im glad to see the couple ppl reply and agree with weight issue
Well for 1, the weight you start at usually isn't your best weight because the average boxer starts lower & matures into a weight class or 2 heavier.
This.
Thread went well.