How did u score the May-Castillo fights?

And I thought the ‘Calzaghe Deception’ was embarrassing. I: Castillo. II. Floyd. I forget the scores, it's fair to point out that Floyd wasn't a 100% in the first fight and was a pretty clear winner the 2nd time around, healthy.

7-4-1 Mayweather.

didnt know that this is old new sorry.... thanks ofr the input though.

I scored the first fight for Mayweather by a few points but it could have gone either way. The second fight I had Mayweather by a margin.

Im not trying to troll i just want to get an idea about how poeplesaw those fights..... i had the first one 115-113 Castillio and the second 116-112 buti think those fightsshow how u could give may problems.... if u cut him of and feint and use head movement oonur way in then work the body allot.... also double up with left hooks to the head and body.... i thin may hasnt fought manyswarmers with great skills. i understand mays shoulder was hurt in the first but in the second castillo still had his moments and castillio seemed clearly frustrated in the second and if he kept composed he could hve done better... maybe not win but do better. ur thoughts? Interesting..... Close fight. Castillo definitely had more moments as the fight wore on. Too bad he lost the first 5 rounds. I had Mayweather winning 114-112. Topic has been beaten to death.

Both of them for Floyd The first fight JLC lost at least 5 of the first six rounds and won no more than 4 of the last six, with no knock downs can't win a fight that way. A close fight though JLC coming on at the end certainly sent a strong perception to people. The second fight was much more like the first six rounds of the first fight but JLC did have some moments.

The only way to get an accurate assessment is to have Floyd fight a guy with a torn rotator cuff. Like in the first Castillo fight. This topic has been beat to death. THIS. Why doesn't the OP do a search for one of the 2500 threads made on this topic.

The only way to get an accurate assessment is to have Floyd fight a guy with a torn rotator cuff. Like in the first Castillo fight. This topic has been beat to death.