Manny Pacquiao as an ATG?

if he beats floyd top 30 He beats Floyd, He'll be #1 ATG

Its hard to start going about how you are going to judge someone who hasnt campaigned at the weight for his whole career. Lets say Cotto and Clottey are top 20 ATG WWs, and have fought 100s of fights at WW. Pac comes along and beats them like he did do. You have to rate Pac above them as an ATG WW. Even though Cotto and Clottey won way more WW fights than Pac.

As a WELTERWEIGHT ATG? Not even in the top 100. As an overall ATG: Just outside top 10. If he beats Mayweather, I'd put him top 3. why would a mayweather win put him fromtop 10 to top three? thats a HUGE jump

haha you people are insane even without the floyd fight hes top 10 atg the guy is truly a legend his accomplishments speak for themselves stop hating for one second in your life and show the man some respect

Beating Mosley, Cotto and Clottey make him an ATG Welter ?. :thinking:.

As a WELTERWEIGHT ATG? Not even in the top 100. As an overall ATG: Just outside top 10. If he beats Mayweather, I'd put him top 3.

take the test!

Nobody Dominates welter like Pac! He's not even a welter! TOP 3 for me!

Manny Pacquiao will never be an ATG since he is: 1). Not an American 2). A midget 3). He doesn't have Duckweather on his resume. 4). Midgets can't be fighting from Flyweight to Junior Middleweight since only the A-side meth can do that to a person. Why A-side meth? Of all the drugs to mention by Duckweather Sr. why methamphetamine? Is it because it is also called speed drug? Methamphetamine: It increases alertness, concentration, energy, and in high doses, can induce euphoria, enhance self-esteem, and increase libido. How much does Duckweather Sr. knows about crystal meth use? "In 1993, Floyd Sr. was convicted for drug trafficking and jailed for five years. He was also guilty of smuggling cocaine in boxes of laundry detergent." Source: DigitalJournal.com 5). Also, a midget going up in weight classes, Duckweather family would like people to believe it is impossible but these men would like to have a word with them: Alabama Kid (Clarence Reeves) - Many of these international fighters are included in the Arnold Thomas collection, including Clarence Reeves, the ‘Alabama Kid’. Reeves spent 10 years in Australia and fought at least 72 matches here. According to a note on the back of his photograph he even married an Australian girl, but was eventually forced to return to America by the White Australia Policy. http://boxrec.com/list_bouts.php?human_id=012452&cat=boxer Willie Meehan - Famous for never training or doing any roadwork whatsoever. He ate whatever and whenever he wanted. Fought in all divisions from flyweight to heavyweight. As a rotund heavyweight, it was said, "..He is so fat, blows do not make an impression on him, and he is so awkward, that even the cleverest of opponents can find no way to reach him effectively..." After his boxing career, Meehan became a production electrician for Hollywood movie studios. The modern boxer named Eric "Butterbean" Esch would be a great company for Willie Meehan. Mickey Taylor - fought a couple of fights from Flyweight to Lightweight. Made his mark from the Welterweight to Heavyweight divisions. And there are more boxers like them. Why are they not champions? They were but they held regional titles, national titles, but never the world titles. One champion for each division not like in today's era of 4 champions and have 17 weight classes. Much like how there are more soccer world titles, tennis world titles, swimming world titles, basketball world titles, baseball world titles, and so forth. 6). Midget Pacquiao is continuously discredited by the American media much like how dominating the Klitschko are but they never seem to get the credit they deserve. Klitschkos and Pacquiao will never get full credit because they don't live in the U.S. because American boxing is getting owned everywhere by Mexicans, Puerto Ricans, Japanese, Filipinos, Canadians, and the whole continent of Europe. Only way Americans get their belts is by cheating the system much like how the WBC copied the American way (WBA & IBF) of stripping champions of their belts. WBC the poor Mexican man's copy of the American way of cheating boxers of their future and money. At least, the WBA and IBF can say to WBC we never got sued by a boxer for a stupid move of stripping a boxer of his championship belt. "On March 21, 1998 Rocchigiani won the fight and a WBC belt; in the subsequent WBC rankings, he was listed as "Light-Heavyweight World Champion." Jones, however, had a change of heart and asked if the WBC would reinstate him as the champion. In a move that violated nearly a dozen of its own regulations, the WBC granted the reinstatement. Rocchigiani received a letter from the WBC advising that the publishing of his name as champion was a typographical error, and he had never really been the official titleholder. Rocchigiani immediately filed a lawsuit against the WBC in a U.S. federal court, claiming that the organization's actions both were contrary to their own rules and injurious to his earning potential (due to diminished professional stature). On May 7, 2003, the judge ruled in Rocchigiani's favor, awarding him $30 million (U.S.) in damages and reinstating him as a former WBC Champion (Rocchigiani had lost a bout since his WBC Title match). The following day, the WBC sought protection by filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy (i.e., corporate debt restructuring) in Puerto Rico. The organization then spent the next 13 months attempting to negotiate a six-figure settlement with Rocchigiani, but Rocchigiani did not at first accept. On June 11, 2004, the WBC announced it would enter Chapter 7 bankruptcy liquidation (i.e., business closing and total asset sell-off) proceedings, effectively ending its existence. This action prompted some in the boxing community to plead with Rocchigiani to settle the dispute, which he did in mid-July 2004." Source: Look at all the newspapers out there. The end. NAH, Manny Pacquiao is legitimately at the Top 10 ATG fighters. Bert Sugar said so. Larry Merchant said so. Al Bernstein said so. And the ROCK said so because it doesn't matter what you say so. :chairshot

As a WW ATG? He's not an WW ATG. Really Pac is not an ATG in any division...Maybe Featherweight....Maybe? I doubt it... He's an ATG fighter P4P...Not in a particular division but overall.

if he beats floyd top 30