I think he would have beaten Lewis. The way he stood toe toe with Tua impressed me, even though this could have been the reason he lost his marbles. My dad and i used to argue about this, even though back then i was rooting for Lewis, as i gotten older i realized this man was the complete package..good chin, speed power, stamina. He would, has someone said earlier, been the real nightmare for any fighter who faced him. Most ppl run away from Tua's power this man made Tua run.