Mayweather shouldn't be on the P4P list if he is not fighting this year?

War Guzman, the pride of the Dominican Republic! :boxing:

If he doesn't have another fight scheduled by May 1st he will. Anyways people care way too much about P4P rankings. He probably care mores about the fact that someone is seen as an equal to him rather than some magazine's ranking.

the whole world is only demanding floyd - pac fight. What does that have to do with floyd's spot on the list? manny was offered a fight with 14 day cutoff, 50/50 purse split, and Floyd would pay $10 million per pound weight penalty. manny rejected that offer. Why?

Floyd hasn't fought in 8 months. Shane was on the p4p list for 16 months after Margarito. Nobody advocated taking him off. the whole world is only demanding floyd - pac fight.

True but Mosley was pursuing fights and then was in training camp for Berto. Floyd has only stated he is on vacation and has not made any mention of fighting anytime soon. This May will be a year of inactivity and if he doesn't fight soon after that I would say drop him lower or out of the ranks. Let's not rewrite history. Floyd was signed (in May) to fight Marquez in September. Manny was pretty much locked in to fight Cotto immediately after hatton. It was clear that Shane was not getting manny. So, tell me which fights Shane was pursuing from May onward. Mosley was talking about manny, and manny was signed to fight Cotto in Nov. It's an unofficial list, people.

It is not "official". There's nothing "OFFICIAL" about it. It is just the most widely respected. ok cool, just wanted to know what everybody used on here to base their arguments for p4p and so forth...

Well I still leave him on mine due to the fact he's still hovering around the sport and is likely to fight this year. But I can see why people would take him off, he's sadly turned into a part time boxer like Oscar in his later years.

yea the ring is the only official p4p list that matters It is not "official". There's nothing "OFFICIAL" about it. It is just the most widely respected.

but mosley was actively trying to fight manny and floyd....then actually signed to fighter berto.. He signed to fight Berto well after 8 months. Also, BHop has had those extended breaks. I guess the p4p list made by a magazine isn't all that compelling for me. I don't view it as a big deal. At all. A p4p list is just someone's opinion. Prior to 2007, I NEVER saw a Manny Pacquiao fan who viewed the p4p list as very important.

who's p4p list is the most regarded or matters the most? the ring? yea the ring is the only official p4p list that matters

Floyd hasn't fought in 8 months. Shane was on the p4p list for 16 months after Margarito. Nobody advocated taking him off. True but Mosley was pursuing fights and then was in training camp for Berto. Floyd has only stated he is on vacation and has not made any mention of fighting anytime soon. This May will be a year of inactivity and if he doesn't fight soon after that I would say drop him lower or out of the ranks.

who's p4p list is the most regarded or matters the most? the ring?

Floyd hasn't fought in 8 months. Shane was on the p4p list for 16 months after Margarito. Nobody advocated taking him off. but mosley was actively trying to fight manny and floyd....then actually signed to fighter berto..

Floyd hasn't fought in 8 months. Shane was on the p4p list for 16 months after Margarito. Nobody advocated taking him off.

agree.....