does the winner of alexander-bradley deserve to crack the p4p list??

well i mean the best 140 definitely needs to be on p4p list. and alexander and bradley are the top fighters.

There's what 17 weight divisions and the top fighter in each can't crack top 10 Yes 140 is one of the best weight divisions but neither fighter has really fought The big dogs yet Bradley deserves it for sure, not devon After he beats Bradley, what will be your opinion?

personal oppinions aside..fact is alexander is undefeated Larry how the fuk you gonna make a thread about people's personal opinions and then say "personal opinions aside"? lol

Should the #1 fighter in 1 of boxing's most stacked division crack the top 10 pfp??Seriously??People pay far too much attention to pfp as it is,but if the top fighter in 1 of boxing's toughest weightclasses can't crack the top 10 pfp,then they might as well do away with it altogether. There's what 17 weight divisions and the top fighter in each can't crack top 10 Yes 140 is one of the best weight divisions but neither fighter has really fought The big dogs yet Bradley deserves it for sure, not devon

If Bradley wins in dominating fashion then yeah he might be a consideration. Just shows how shiit the P4P lists are though, in all honesty.

Bradley would but Alexander wouldn't because he lost his last fight against Kotelnik. personal oppinions aside..fact is alexander is undefeated

It depends on how the fight goes and how the winner wins. If its a 12 round shitfest, then neither deserve to be on the list. If one guy clearly destroys the other, then an argument can be made for a late spot on the list. I agree. both have got to give great performances when they fight despite the lack of attendance. if both give at FOTY type fight/performance, then both will get on the top 10 p4p list. however if both stink out the joint, both should not be in the top 10

IMO... No one that is only a 1 division champion should be on the p4p list period... Its easy to stay in your weight class and beat everybody there, say you're the best and wait till someone better comes along? Divisional championships are what define boxers, their will and desire to be the best..... Your post is made of a lot of fail. When a fighter grows out of his original weight class it is not a credit to him when he decides to move up a weight class. The only thing that should matter is the quality of your opposition.

IMO... No one that is only a 1 division champion should be on the p4p list period... Its easy to stay in your weight class and beat everybody there, say you're the best and wait till someone better comes along? Divisional championships are what define boxers, their will and desire to be the best..... bullsh1t its harder to remain dedicated and keep making weight and beat everyone who enters your division than to jump weight and fight the weakest champion in each division

Who knows how Ring Magazine would position the winner, but if it was me to decide I'd put Bradley at #8 (can't put him over Montiel). If Alexander wins, I'd put him in Bradley's #9 position.

damn didnt know timmy was already on da list

Bradley would but Alexander wouldn't because he lost his last fight against Kotelnik.

IMO... No one that is only a 1 division champion should be on the p4p list period... Its easy to stay in your weight class and beat everybody there, say you're the best and wait till someone better comes along? Divisional championships are what define boxers, their will and desire to be the best..... Actually that is not so easy at all.

If Bradley wins then maybe but if Devon wins just outside for me.

IMO... No one that is only a 1 division champion should be on the p4p list period... Its easy to stay in your weight class and beat everybody there, say you're the best and wait till someone better comes along? Divisional championships are what define boxers, their will and desire to be the best.....

After he loses, Bradley will drop on everyone's list. #thatwaseasy

On second thought, I don't think devon cracks the list with a win over Bradley His win over Tim will be like pascals win over Dawson and he didn't crack the top 10 Agree with this.

On second thought, I don't think devon cracks the list with a win over Bradley His win over Tim will be like pascals win over Dawson and he didn't crack the top 10

Should the #1 fighter in 1 of boxing's most stacked division crack the top 10 pfp??Seriously??People pay far too much attention to pfp as it is,but if the top fighter in 1 of boxing's toughest weightclasses can't crack the top 10 pfp,then they might as well do away with it altogether.

Bradley is already on my list, I don't know about the rest.