Cotto at 140lbs going toe-to-toe with Maidana...who wins?

if it's 2005, i don't think madaina looked any diffrent than torres. i'd fully expect cotto to beat him. same...I actually see that fight playing out like Cotto-Torres.

if it's 2005, i don't think madaina looked any diffrent than torres. i'd fully expect cotto to beat him.

you're talking now, or hypothetical? A 2005 Cotto

you're talking now, or hypothetical?

Cotto is Maidana's superior in every way except one: power. Maidana has freakish punching power in both hands and the Torres fight showed that if Cotto thinks he has you hurt, you can get to him with a bomb and it will affect him. I would favor Cotto to win just on sheer gulf of class, but I wouldn't bet on it and there is a decent chance that Maidana catches Cotto on the chin and puts him to sleep.

Cotto would be a dead man walking at 140 lbs sooo.. Maidana