Ahhhh......no...not yet anyway
No...huge fan but dont agree hes the greatest ever...if he goes on to beat Manny and Martinez then he would be the best fighter I have ever seen as I have not seen all of Sugar Ray Robinsons fights...
I think his the best of his generation, but all time to me is irrelevant as each person will favour the boxers of their era's. The boxing writers in twenty years time will have a much different list to the like of Bert Sugars...he seems to overrate the old timers imo...
http://img163.imageshack.us/img163/2661/floydmayweatherjr.jpg
Is Floyd Mayweather the Greatest Boxer of All Time?
participate in the poll ^ above
http://i28.tinypic.com/i1e0i1.jpg
No,
He can't even convince his fellow Americans - The Boxing Writers Association of America to be their Boxer/fighter of the the Decade!
He is not alone of having no defeats. Now a days, you can see a lot of Latinos, Cubans and even Russians parading a No defeat Records.
He can't even give what boxing fans wants: The Pacman-Mayweather Fight.
His Derogatory Police Records certainly tarnished whatever good records he has in Boxing.
When you say "All Time Great", you have to put into consideration whatever World Record that was accomplished that is very hard to duplicate!
http://img163.imageshack.us/img163/2661/floydmayweatherjr.jpg
Is Floyd Mayweather the Greatest Boxer of All Time?
participate in the poll ^ above
LOL.........are you joking? Floyd is a scrub!!!!
No...but I do think he is top 5 talent wise. IMO he is more skilled/talented than Ali, Roy, Leonard, Haglar and others.
I have Duran, Pep, Robinson above him though in that department, but all of that means nothing, unless he actually shows it against elite level opposition.
As far as what the essence of the sweet science is "Hit and do not get hit"... He's probably the purest example of that since Muhammad Ali. Equal to, if not more so. But as far as actual greatness... HELL NO
The only light/welterweights I would pick against Floyd are Duran and Tito. PBF is in my top 6 P4P of the last 20 years
RJJ
Hopkins
Tito
Marquez
Pacman