Rules:
1. Take both fighters from their best showing at 168.
2. Anyone who utters the phrase "46-0" will be punished.
http://static.boxrec.com/wiki/a/a2/Michael_Nunn1.jpg
VS
http://s.bebo.com/app-image/7926350997/5411656627/PROFILE/i.quizzaz.com/img/q/u/08/03/29/joe-calzaghe19.jpg
Calzaghe would probably win imo, Nunn would give him problems early but would get outworked down the stretch imo, Nunn could not handle pressure that well (Iran Barkley,Rocchigiani), plus he liked to clown way too much.
To me Nunn was the type of guy that wanted to fight when he wanted to fight, not when you wanted him to fight.
Ive seen his fights with Roldan, Parker, Barkley, Toney, Yonker, Starling, Kalambay, Tate, Curry, Rocchigiani, that is what i gather from the fights ive seen anyway.
I reckon Nunn would give Roy Jones more issues than he would Calzaghe, although i think Jones beat Calzaghe in his prime.
I understand what you're saying. It's just JCC Jr. is too skilled for Valuev. It wouldn't last 4 rounds.
I hate to say this, but I think you're biased.