12-0 vs 12-0

ok everybody wlad and manny are both 12 and 0 in their last 12 Wlad: fought 5 undefeated fighters, 2 with loss 2 with 2 losses 2 with 3 losses and 1 with more than 3 losses (6). manny: fought 1 undefeated fighter, 3 with 1 loss, none with 2 losses, 3 with 3 losses and 5 with more (4,4,5,5, and 10) i think people are overrating manny's recent run to an extent as a lot of the fighters he's faced have been old or over the hill. barrera, oscar, morales (3rd fight), larios, and velasquez were clearly over the hill and had little chance of winning. solis also had little chance of winning. thats 6 out of his last 12 had no chance. if you look at wlads opponents, rahman is the only one who was clearly old and over the hill. maybe you could put brewster in this category. guys who had no chance: williamson, castillo, and ray austin. thats 4 or 5 who had no chance. looking past those 6 and 5 fighters... manny beat morales in a rematch, marquez, david diaz, ricky hatton, miguel cotto and clottey. morales rematch: great win at the time, revenge for his last loss marquez: too close to call, barely a win. david diaz, great performance against inferior opposition. tko win hatton: great performance against a half drunk fighter who was maybe 1 year past his best, but lackin in motivation. KO cotto: great performance against another fighter 1 year from his prime. for cotto and hatton these were a punishing year though, cotto b/c of the marg beating hatton, b/c of booze more so than the ko loss to floyd. TKO clottey: great performance against an ok fighter. did what he had to do UD Wlad beat chambers, chagaev, thompson, ibragimov, brock, byrd and peter. chambers: great performance, shutout against a good fighter, KO chagaev: great performance against a very good undefeated champion (if not for b/s politics), TKO thompson: similar to david diaz fight, in that he beat inferior opposition but ended in a KO. ibragimov: great performance over very good undefeated champion (UD). didnt lose a round. Brock: great performance and KO against an undefeated prospect who was on a nice run at the time. Byrd: great performance against a champ who had probably seen better days a year or two ago, but who wlad had beaten before in his best days. TKO. Peter: solid boxing, against an undefeated power punching prospect who later became champion. UD my point is mannys run is not much (if any) more impressive than wlads, and wlad is at least #3 p4p.