Where Do You Currently Rate Pacquaio and Mayweather, All Time?

Once again, if floyd is barely a top 50 fighter, how does that vault manny to number one? Coz nobody left!! Pac has fought and beat all the top guys.

pac is ranked higher than jesus. :banana: agreed Jesus Perez and Jesus Martinez are nobodies compared to Manny. :boxing:

pac is ranked higher than jesus. :banana:

well...just by using the BWAA FOTD award as an arbitrary measuring stick...(no I don't mean to sound like Nathanielsz here) 50s - SRR 60s - Ali 70s - Duran 80s - SRL 90s - RJJ 2000-2009 - Pac apparently Boxing writers (you know, the ones who write about boxing for a living, the ones with credentials, experience, and knowledge...and no matter what you NSB posters think, you're NOT one of them)...they held Pacquiao in high-enough regard that they gave him a LANDSLIDE victory for the award. There wasn't even a close vote. Sure the BWAA are "morons" according to most Floyd fans, but they also CORRECTLY picked the most deserving recipient for each decade (maybe 90s could've gone to Evander). Still, those are some pretty accurate morons. Every fighter of the decade since at least the 50s is regarded as an ATG....with Roy being criticized for his losses to Tarver and Johnson. Once he lost the speed, it seems his boxing skills diminished. So where does this put Manny Pacquiao? That's an interesting question. And according to the BWAA, it puts him pretty damn high on the ATG list.

Both between top20-30. Its laughable to have any of them top10. id say your right but i guess its all subjective.

There are three ATG level in boxing. First level: Ali, SRRobinson, Armstrong..... Second level: SRLeonard, Duran, Jones Jr..... Third level: Dela Hoya, Mosley, Morales..... 20yrs form now Pac will be mention along with the fighters from the first level. Floyd with all the talent that he has will be in the third level. I think Manny is 20-25,Floyd 30-40. Floyd never fought a real threat. Mosley wasn't a great threat,he was 39,and get beat by Cotto and DLH younger(robbery rematch)and Marquez is a midget at 147 it's not even funny. Now,Mosley was still a very decent threat,and Floyd beat him easy.Floyd is full of talent,a P4P picasso. But Manny fought real threats,Barrera was,Cotto was a great threat for a blown up featherweight. And Manny dominated and also stopped them.

There are three ATG level in boxing. First level: Ali, SRRobinson, Armstrong..... Second level: SRLeonard, Duran, Jones Jr..... Third level: Dela Hoya, Mosley, Morales..... 20yrs form now Pac will be mention along with the fighters from the first level. Floyd with all the talent that he has will be in the third level.

Both between top20-30. Its laughable to have any of them top10.

Pac is already at the top 5 ATG. Floyd barely makes top 50. After Pac KOs Floyd, Pac will be ranked at the TOP at Numero UNO. Floyd will stay around 50. Once again, if floyd is barely a top 50 fighter, how does that vault manny to number one?

Pac is already at the top 5 ATG. Floyd barely makes top 50. After Pac KOs Floyd, Pac will be ranked at the TOP at Numero UNO. Floyd will stay around 50.

Legacy and ability are two diferent things. RJJ probably ability wise could be a top ten fighter but legacy wise due to his ducking is probably only a top 80 ATG. Mayweather ability wise is a top 30 ATG, if Pac beats him then hes beaten another prime ATG. Pacs resume doesnt need PBF all he needs is another belt at 154 and a win over another solid fighter such as Margarito. RJJ ONLY TOP 80?????????? WHAT THE ****??? :smashfrea:smashfrea:smashfrea: lmao. What other PRIME "ATG" has pac beaten? But your still missing the point im trying to make. You say, after its all said and done, that mayweather is only top 50 on the ATG list. So if pac beats him, why is he then vaulted to number 1?

So a win over a top 50 atg whose legacy is tarnished by his cherrypicking puts pac as the number one p4p of all time? Where is your logic? LMAO I love that you called him on his foolish "Pacaganda" again, if manny did beat Floyd there tune would change to Floyd is the best ever...behind Manny I can already see those kind of posts from the same people who claim Floyd is only top 50 while the catchweight drug test dodging Manny is rated top 10 fighting zombies that Floyd beat first in meaningful fights.

Pacquiao is something between 25-30 Floyd is something between 45-55

Pacquiao is already a top 10 ATG Win over Margarito and a belt in an 8th weight class OR a win over PBF and he goes ahead of SRR. Mayweather is a top 50 ATG. His legacy is tarnished by his cherrypicking so he will never be regarded on the same level as the likes of Duran, Pac and SRR etc. Unlikely to beat Pac but if he does than that elevates him to a top 20 atg. :rofl::rofl::rofl: :tool:

Pacquiao is already a top 10 ATG Win over Margarito and a belt in an 8th weight class OR a win over PBF and he goes ahead of SRR. Mayweather is a top 50 ATG. His legacy is tarnished by his cherrypicking so he will never be regarded on the same level as the likes of Duran, Pac and SRR etc. Unlikely to beat Pac but if he does than that elevates him to a top 20 atg. So a win over a top 50 atg whose legacy is tarnished by his cherrypicking puts pac as the number one p4p of all time? Where is your logic?

...bump...