Wich of these 2 defeats by roy jones was more surprising .

I really cannot say because i have never been a fan of either fighter but judging from the fights tarver really disliked jones whereas johnson just seems to not give him the respect other fights did. Maybe it was the fact that jones was already past his prime that them defeats happened but would he had beaten them in his prime really,i mean tarver beats just twice after losing to him before and johnson beat jones just after tarver.