top 5 p4p no real arguments

pac floyd mosley bute martinez ward pwill

I am surprised no one has Nonito Donaire on here, quality little fighter with good wins on his resume, i would agree with your origional list but replace Williams for Donaire because Williams needs to dominate one division and getting a few belts b4 being up there p4p wise donaire should be ahead of pac

its all a matter of opinion

I am surprised no one has Nonito Donaire on here, quality little fighter with good wins on his resume, i would agree with your origional list but replace Williams for Donaire because Williams needs to dominate one division and getting a few belts b4 being up there p4p wise

Thats not bad, depends on what you like better. Do you like Dawson's consistency and domination of his own division which he is slowly cleaning out, or do you like Sergio's display of skills in a fight he as robbed in against a decent opponent, a fight he lost that could have gone his way against p4p rated PWill, and his domination of then MW champion KP while he is much smaller than him? It makes sense when you word it like that. Dawson and Martinez you can basically flip flop back and forth. You're right.

Pac Mayweather Mosley Williams Dawson Martinez should be above Williams and in the top 5 because he beat Williams, Cintron, and Pavlik.

Martinez win over Pavlik is better than anything dawson has accomplished. Lets not get crazy. Dawson is 5-0. Vs. Top 5 175 Pounders.

1. Pacquiao 2. Mayweather 3. Mosley 4. Martinez 5. Williams

Martinez win over Pavlik is better than anything dawson has accomplished.

Pac Mayweather Mosley Williams Dawson