Should Cotto be rematching Margarito to avenge his brutal and contoversial defeat?

if cotto were planning on fighting for more than two fights, than i say yes. but since he is only planning on a couple more, i say no.

It is unbelieveable that ppl still doubt that they caught Margo trying to cheat. Naz went on 24/7 to say what he found. CSAC suspendend him with illeagal substance in his gloves. Margo would become a millionare suing everybody and he hasn't cause he was caught. Dude is a cheat

I think he should

:nono: no more feria for margie :nono:

People are going to say he doesn't deserve a rematch because of his supposed attempt to cheat. Margarito's ghost will forever haunt Cotto, no doubt about that. You'll see how all the Cotto stans won't want to see a fight because they don't want to see traumatized Cotto go through another beating and back it by saying Margarito doesn't deserve another dime. Agreed!!!!!! It would end Cotto's career if he loses again to AM. Even though its SPECULATION that he possibly cheated .... there's no proof. And if AM walks Cotto down and punishes him ..... Its over.

cotto should ask for 90 percent of the purse. I am a cotto fan but I would watch the fight if it happen. But it has to make business sense for cotto

Cotto should see him on the street. No money, no gloves.

Rematch, I would love to see it. There's no proof Margarito cheated.

If and whenever Margarito gets his license to fight in the States again, that fight should definitely be considered and it would be a big hit. But Cotto's not gonna go to Mexico to fight for peanuts just to get revenge. They have to make that a huge event.

An unbeaten fighter loses to a man later found to have gloves with a substance somewhat like plaster of paris on them in a brutal fashion. Who knows what this did to Cotto mentally, but he may never have got over it. If I were him I'd be rematching Margarito ASAP to erase the ghosts of the past. Should he give another payday to a "cheat"? Or does he just need to move on with his career and forget Margarito ever happened? yes, he needs to get revenge on margo.

People are going to say he doesn't deserve a rematch because of his supposed attempt to cheat. Margarito's ghost will forever haunt Cotto, no doubt about that. You'll see how all the Cotto stans won't want to see a fight because they don't want to see traumatized Cotto go through another beating and back it by saying Margarito doesn't deserve another dime. I agree. The only people that know if he did cheat in the fight are Capetillo and Margarito himself. If I felt someone had cheated me and that was the only reason they beat me I would want to take that rematch in a heartbeat, because I know I would beat them. It's not about money, it's about revenge and make him pay. If I was so confident I would even bet my purse for that night and winner take all. That simple.

An unbeaten fighter loses to a man later found to have gloves with a substance somewhat like plaster of paris on them in a brutal fashion. Who knows what this did to Cotto mentally, but he may never have got over it. If I were him I'd be rematching Margarito ASAP to erase the ghosts of the past. Should he give another payday to a "cheat"? Or does he just need to move on with his career and forget Margarito ever happened? Hell yeah, Miguel needs to rematch Margarito, and avenge that loss... That dude might have cheated you. Cotto should be looking for big pay back against that "SOB"...without ?!

Ideally, yes. Cotto feels cheated and his way of sticking it to Margarito is monetarily. He'd have to go in there with another game plan though, and copy Mosley's style. You can't beat Margarito backpedaling. It's not going to happen, this is why I would have had him beating Pac before the Mosley beating, as I'm unsure if this chin is cracked. Cotto has enough power if he is moving forward or plants himself, the style he used for the fight will never beat Margs.

Shouldn't it be Margarito who is saying that he wants to fight Cotto for free to remove all doubts? I guess it shows he knows he didn't beat Cotto fairly.

there is no proof margo cheated. he cant forget that margo never happened because it did happen. the nevada commission watches hand wraps in that fight and people need to stop making those hand wrap excuses every single time. it is boring now, look just face the truth, margo was better on the night and won. simple as that

An unbeaten fighter loses to a man later found to have gloves with a substance somewhat like plaster of paris on them in a brutal fashion. Who knows what this did to Cotto mentally, but he may never have got over it. If I were him I'd be rematching Margarito ASAP to erase the ghosts of the past. Should he give another payday to a "cheat"? Or does he just need to move on with his career and forget Margarito ever happened? He should have an exhibition match(without head-gear on) against him so Margarito doesn't make any money from it. Do those still exists or are they mainly only in movies?