Ricky Hatton or Joe Calzaghe, Who Should Rank Higher On A ATG List?

I'm a Hatton fan and he's my favorite European fighter followed by Arthur Abraham but Calzaghe is higher in the ATG list.

Zags is top 50 IMO. Hagler is the only guy in the 160-175 weight range Id rank above him. Theres like 20 guys I could name at that weight that should be ahead of Calzaghe. I know hes your boy but all hes done is beat Kessler. Thats it.

Zags is top 50 IMO. Hagler is the only guy in the 160-175 weight range Id rank above him. Ezzard Charles? Harry Greb? Carlos Monzon? Archie Moore? Bob Fitzsimmons? I mean I could keep naming guys but come on all these fighters are ranked over Hagler or should be IMO let alone Calzaghe.

Hatton definatley

Calzaghe obviously. Hattons best win is a shot Kosta or a gate keeper named Collazo. Zags is top 50 IMO. Hagler is the only guy in the 160-175 weight range Id rank above him.

can i see your top 400 ATG's, no ceilings Calzaghe is ass. Deal with it sir.

Calzaghe, not close.

can i see your top 400 ATG's, no ceilings :boxing: man im sure Milton will gave you his list he has nothing to do just give him time bro...he can even make it 500 ATG's list....go ahead Milton...:lew:

super Joe Calzaghe

Who would be higher do? Calzaghe obviously. Hattons best win is a shot Kosta or a gate keeper named Collazo.

They are both in 300-350 range. Who would be higher do?

They are both not in the top 200 so it doesnt matter.

Joe Calzaghe

Seeing how Ricky Hatton doesn't make the list I'd have to go with Joe Calzaghe.