How good is Maidana?????

maidana's power will drop any1 at 140

Exciting but overrated. He'll soon be outboxed

let's not overrate him too much just yet guys. Don't forgot he lost to Kotelnik not long ago and khan destroyed him. Maidana is being overrated, he'll lose to almost anyone who can box well at this point imo. Pretty Much.. Valero-Maidana would be great while it lasts tho..

for me he's just an average boxer but with a lot of power. so scaled him to 5.

for me he's just an average boxer bot with a lot of power. so scaled him to 5.

He's a tough, relentless warrior that will give hell to anyone they put in front of him. Right now you have to rate him at least 3 or 4 best in the division.

Number one imo but i can see why some people put him 2nd, he is the paul williams of jnr welterweight division

He's not that great. All power, but put him in there with Bradley, Alexander, Khan, even Paulie and watch what happens..

the top boxers like khan,bradley,alexander will beat him hes a tough brawler but if kotenlik can beat him im sure those 3 can

He is a gladiator from argentina!:boxing: http://www.boxnews.com.ua/photos/1717/Marcos-Rene-Maidana5.jpg

He's a brawler, does well against contenders but when it comes to the real tight boxers at the top of the division like Alexander, Bradley and Khan he will get outboxed severly. Besides, i think Ortiz would have beat him if he had carried on and not quit.

i have him at 5

3/4, good pucnher, good to see how he deals witha pure boxer like alexander

In which places at junior welterweight you put Marcos Maidana??? 4, behind #1. Alexander #2.Bradley and #3. Khan.

Good enough to beat Khan in the first 3 rounds I'll tell you that.

IMO he is the 4th or 5th best JWW.

whoever voted 10 is an asshole

In which places at junior walterweight you put Marcos Maidana??? well hes capable of getting off the canvas multiple times and still dropping his opponent, although he isnt anything spectacular skillswise he is capable of beating the best in the division.

Maidana has strong hands and a tough warrior attitude. Anyone smart enough to sit on the outside and box Maidana would win easily. That being said Maidana is on Urango's level IMO. Bradley, Alexander, Khan, or Malignaggi all outbox him without a problem. Only the guys that want to sit and slug with him get KTFO. I'd love to see Maidana versus Urango, Valero, Guzman, or Judah.

I'm an idiot. I thought you meant rate him on a scale 1 through 10. Bradley Alexander Khan Nate Campbell 5. Maidana nate campbell over maidana????????:wtf1: