Joe Calzaghe vs Andre Dirrell @ 168 - Who Wins?

I got "not so average Joe" on this one with bunch of experience and trickx in his arsenal he beat Bhop he beat Roy he would beat Andre

Joe would beat Andre after a three day bender in Ibiza on just a few hours sleep. And it wouldn't even be competitive. I don't think people appreciate how skilled Joe really was, no surprise honestly, but he was a Mayweather/Pacquaio level talent at his best. He just didn't have the opponents to prove it against unfortunately, Bernard wanted no parts of Joe and Roy had bigger fish to fry at the time.

The way Andre looked on Saturday against AA vs. the way Joe looked against Roy. I have to go with Andre. Andre has enough pop to make Joe have to reset. Andre was surgical with the double and triple straight lefts and was fluid in his switch from southpaw to ortho, change of direction and shifting of angles as well as not forgeting about the body using the jab to the body to create space. I think that if Joe started a combo, Andre could and would interrupt it with a precision shot and then turn him.

LOL. Let's see, Dirrell moves backwards, Calzaghe moves forwards, Calzaghe throws and lands more punches. Bit of a no-brainer. Dirrell doesn't really hit that hard for Calzaghe either, so I can't see him putting a dent in Calzaghe. I'd like to see Joe vs AA. Would be hilarious. Joe would get a premature stoppage after throwing 402 shots in combination without reply. Enzo runs in and AA sucker punches him. lol true!!!

I voted for Calzaghe by KO since the crack will give him extra power. LOL. Let's see, Dirrell moves backwards, Calzaghe moves forwards, Calzaghe throws and lands more punches. Bit of a no-brainer. Dirrell doesn't really hit that hard for Calzaghe either, so I can't see him putting a dent in Calzaghe. I'd like to see Joe vs AA. Would be hilarious. Joe would get a premature stoppage after throwing 402 shots in combination without reply. Enzo runs in and AA sucker punches him.

I voted for Calzaghe by KO since the crack will give him extra power.

calzaghe wins a decision he brings to much for anyone in the super 6

Joe Cokezaghe all the way baby he's too much a of real champion for young andre direll IMO joe is smarter has better stamina 4 the later rounds and can give you hell in there

Calzaghe wins, even in his sleep & coked of his face!!!!

Dirrell VIA UD. Joe never boxed anyone as fast.

Dirrell wins an easy UD Welcome To Boxing Scene Jr...im sure Loccy Sr will be proud..

Joe wouldent have fought him anyway.

Calzaghe by wide UD, might even floor him once or twice! Calzaghe is too experienced.

Joke thread, Calzaghe slaps the shit out of dirrell.

Dirrell is an amateur who still makes amateur mistakes.

Calzaghe, and it wouldnt be close.

Two of these threads. ... Like I said in the other thread, I think Calzaghe would win. Yeah, I messed up. I made a topic before I knew this one existed! Mines a public poll though so you know how ppl feel about the fight. Basically, so ppl can't hide their opinions! :rofl:

Two of these threads. ... Like I said in the other thread, I think Calzaghe would win.

Bump, I found the topic... Mods can delete my topic.

calzaghe would besat them all easily