How is Pac a top 5 ATG if he beats the winner of Mayweather-Mosley?

Some people here are saying that Pac would be top 5 in the ATG category if he beats Mosley or Floyd and as much as I am a Pac fan, I don't see how he is top 5 material. Top 10 YES but top 5? He has to contend with: Ali Robinson Duran Leonard Hagler and thats 5 guys already. I don't see how he fits into the top 5 ATG list Pac is not top 5 unless he fights another 5+ years and fights all the great welterweights and moves up and dominates middleweight... and that's very doubtful... If he does that theyll find out hes on roids and hell be not even eligible for a top spot.

So what would a fighter today have to do to be considered on YOUR top 5?.. Win every damn division??:confused: Its so much more difficult for fighters today to reach top 10 all time greatness because one they fight so much less often, and two there are to many belts keeping the best from fighting the best, or even all the top contenders. What Pac has done is spectacular. But we can't say he would have done these same things had their only been one title in each division. In no order..... Robinson Armstrong Greb Langford Charles Burley B. Leonard Gans Canzoneri Ross Louis Ali R. Leonard Conn Duran

I'd be surprised and kind of pissed off if people start calling Pac a top 20 fighter once he retires. He's great, but he's not that great.

If he beats Floyd he could go as far inside 20 but if it's Mosley, Pac stays within 25-30. Pac is not going in the top 20 even with a win over Floyd.

Not fight drained or washed up fighters.or fight David Diaz to claim a paper title coming from a guy with a edwin valero avatar......

exactly........... Not fight drained or washed up fighters.or fight David Diaz to claim a paper title

He will never bne Top 10 let alone Top 5. Like Mayweather.

How many rounds did they have to fight back then? How many fights and for how many years did those fighters fight? How frequently did they fight? Sh*t was tougher back then than now is what people have to realize. The same goes for dieting and training.

So what would a fighter today have to do to be considered on YOUR top 5?.. Win every damn division??:confused: exactly...........

Only idiots and his dumbass fans think he's top 5 because the "experts" say so. Yup these same idiots don't got Floyd in the top 50 or Shane yet these wins climb him top 5?

Some people here are saying that Pac would be top 5 in the ATG category if he beats Mosley or Floyd and as much as I am a Pac fan, I don't see how he is top 5 material. Top 10 YES but top 5? He has to contend with: Ali Robinson Duran Leonard Hagler and thats 5 guys already. I don't see how he fits into the top 5 ATG list So what would a fighter today have to do to be considered on YOUR top 5?.. Win every damn division??:confused:

He will never bne Top 10 let alone Top 5.

Only idiots and his dumbass fans think he's top 5 because the "experts" say so.