If Mayweather.....

I don't think he will be the GOAT but to say that he needs to have a run at 160 is a bit unfair considering he started at 130...I dunno man people recently seem to have forgotten his reign and 130 and hold him to a crazy standard. Not that it would necessarily be beyond him to compete at 160 he'd have to keep his reflexes in tact though. you need to change your sig, it distacts me when im trying to read ur posts

as for as making his case to being the GOAT, floyd hasnt done himself any favors with his resume thus far. plus, he only wants 4 more fights, if that. he cant do anything from now til then to surpass anything that SRR has done.

I don't think he will be the GOAT but to say that he needs to have a run at 160 is a bit unfair considering he started at 130...I dunno man people recently seem to have forgotten his reign and 130 and hold him to a crazy standard. Not that it would necessarily be beyond him to compete at 160 he'd have to keep his reflexes in tact though. If you are talking about ranking him in the top 5 all time, a run at 160 is not ridiculous. Henry Armstrong was champion of three different divisions at the same time. Roberto Duran was a lightweight and won super middleweight belts. Tommy Hearns won belts at light heavyweight. Floyd would have to do something similar to be in that discussiion.

I don't think he will be the GOAT but to say that he needs to have a run at 160 is a bit unfair considering he started at 130...I dunno man people recently seem to have forgotten his reign and 130 and hold him to a crazy standard. Not that it would necessarily be beyond him to compete at 160 he'd have to keep his reflexes in tact though.

Jesus christ, I know people find it hard to have perspective when they're caught up in the moment, but this is ridiculous. Floy Mayweather, I despise the guy, but he's clearly an ATG if he beats Mosley and Pacquiao. In such a case he would have reigned in one of the greatest eras ever for the weights he's been in. You're talking about people like Pacquiao, De La Hoya, Mosley, Cotto, Marquez, Judah, Hatton, Margarito, Clottey, Morales, Barrera. All those people have fought each other and Mayweather's fought most of them. If he beat Mosley and Pac he'd be the king of all those guys because either he or Pac would have beaten all those guys yet Mayweather would have also defeated Pac and somehow remained undefeated? That would be incredible. Thank you, if he beats pac and shane this year he's good in my eyes..but it always will be some young guys 2 years from now and everyone will be like he's ducking alexander and bradley..when will enough be enough? There no one at 54 I'd like to see him fight except for a Paul williams maybe.. There will always be challengers out there. We can only compare him realistically to the folks in his own area..I personally never seen Robinson or Lamotta fight except on you tube or espn classic, I wasn't born when they were champs...I couldn't gauge the competition. We don't know the circumstances around those old fights like we know today. 50 years from now folks won't know that clottey didn't have his trainer with him to fight Pac-man..stuff like that happens and we only know cause were from this era.

Jesus christ, I know people find it hard to have perspective when they're caught up in the moment, but this is ridiculous. Floy Mayweather, I despise the guy, but he's clearly an ATG if he beats Mosley and Pacquiao. In such a case he would have reigned in one of the greatest eras ever for the weights he's been in. You're talking about people like Pacquiao, De La Hoya, Mosley, Cotto, Marquez, Judah, Hatton, Margarito, Clottey, Morales, Barrera. All those people have fought each other and Mayweather's fought most of them. If he beat Mosley and Pac he'd be the king of all those guys because either he or Pac would have beaten all those guys yet Mayweather would have also defeated Pac and somehow remained undefeated? That would be incredible. That's exactly what Im saying man, how can you deny this man as an ATG? The ignorance of some is beyond me!

all he has to do to be the goat is whoop on sugar shane and pacquiao. Cus if pacquiao beats mayweather after he beats mosley, people will say he is the goat, so that fight will determine it.

i dont think floyd would even try

Jesus christ, I know people find it hard to have perspective when they're caught up in the moment, but this is ridiculous. Floy Mayweather, I despise the guy, but he's clearly an ATG if he beats Mosley and Pacquiao. In such a case he would have reigned in one of the greatest eras ever for the weights he's been in. You're talking about people like Pacquiao, De La Hoya, Mosley, Cotto, Marquez, Judah, Hatton, Margarito, Clottey, Morales, Barrera. All those people have fought each other and Mayweather's fought most of them. If he beat Mosley and Pac he'd be the king of all those guys because either he or Pac would have beaten all those guys yet Mayweather would have also defeated Pac and somehow remained undefeated? That would be incredible.

This thread belongs here http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=10 Pls post on proper forums. How about not? This doesnt belong in Fantasy fights thread, this was a ? And that ****in question was will people finally give Floyd the credit he deserves and call him GOAT... Not, a fantasy fight thread... so i definitely posted in the proper forum

No, those fights were not against nobodies. Back then you couldn't win paper belts and fight nobodies, if you were a champion in a division you were fighting the best they had to offer. Sugar Ray Robinson fought more great fighters than Pac or Floyd have easily. Yes those fighters then had nobodies, but to get to a level where you were competing for or defending a title, you were beating great fighters. Floyd would have to do A LOT at 147 and 154 along with a decent run at 160 to compete with that. I dont think the 160 run would be needed if he unified all titles in 147 and 154

Yeah but there are more fighters nowadays and more quality opponents, the games evolved so much... Idk man, theres a ton of big names between 140-154 that Floyd could fight and if he won them all id consider him GOAT, other than maybe Ali, but that is a given... I do have to give Ray Robinson respect in the fact the dude fought so many ****in fights, its unbelievable, but most of those fights were probably against nobodys.. No, those fights were not against nobodies. Back then you couldn't win paper belts and fight nobodies, if you were a champion in a division you were fighting the best they had to offer. Sugar Ray Robinson fought more great fighters than Pac or Floyd have easily. Yes those fighters then had nobodies, but to get to a level where you were competing for or defending a title, you were beating great fighters. Floyd would have to do A LOT at 147 and 154 along with a decent run at 160 to compete with that.

Beats Mosley, fights Pacquiao, wins, and finishes off his career with a string of 10 more wins after those fights, against contenders, and does no "ducking" as pac fans like to call it, then would you mofos finally accept hes the GOAT? This thread belongs here http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=10 Pls post on proper forums.

To realistically have a shot at being the GOAT, Mayweather would have to clean out 147, dominate 154, and win the recognized 160 championship and defend it a few times. Fighters today don't get anywhere near the resumes the recognized best of all time do, and Floyd is no where close. Yeah but there are more fighters nowadays and more quality opponents, the games evolved so much... Idk man, theres a ton of big names between 140-154 that Floyd could fight and if he won them all id consider him GOAT, other than maybe Ali, but that is a given... I do have to give Ray Robinson respect in the fact the dude fought so many ****in fights, its unbelievable, but most of those fights were probably against nobodys..

To realistically have a shot at being the GOAT, Mayweather would have to clean out 147, dominate 154, and win the recognized 160 championship and defend it a few times. Fighters today don't get anywhere near the resumes the recognized best of all time do, and Floyd is no where close.

believe me i have seen many sugar ray robinson fights.. But Floyd could put together a string of big name wins at 140/147/154 that I think could catapult him to GOAT status yeah maybe if he beats them all in a fckin battle royale... other than that... no.

believe me i have seen many sugar ray robinson fights.. But Floyd could put together a string of big name wins at 140/147/154 that I think could catapult him to GOAT status I would love to catapult him. I used to be a human cannonball, you know. I got fired though. They said I just wasn't the right caliber for the job. 100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3

i like mayweather technical superiority but goat no. watch any robinson fight. and youll realize how great he was. believe me i have seen many sugar ray robinson fights.. But Floyd could put together a string of big name wins at 140/147/154 that I think could catapult him to GOAT status

http://i869.photobucket.com/albums/ab252/ummmid/1268316549150.gif