If both win who's p4p 1

And when exactly did Pac take the P4P title from Floyd, I dont remember that fight, do you? He retired and could not have the luxury to do so.

If both win I'd still have Pacquiao as number one. The only way this would really change for me is if Pacquiao started picking lower level opposition. They're both fighting challenging opponents, I'd rank Mosley higher than Clottey but not enough to dethrone Pacquiao. Though if Mayweather dominates Mosley and Pacquiao struggles I think Mayweather should go no. 1.

Nope. Floyd must take the title from the p4p champ himself. Doesn't only work that way, but Pacquiao would still be the number 1 P4P.

Nope. Floyd must take the title from the p4p champ himself. And when exactly did Pac take the P4P title from Floyd, I dont remember that fight, do you?

If mayweather and pacman both win do you think the rankings will change ? would you change them ? that's a matter of opinion, I'd give PBF the p4p title.

http://www.wedoiteverymonth.com/assets_c/2009/10/Nature+Boy+Ric+Flair-thumb-400x433-1517.jpg "To be the man, you have to beat the man! Wooo"! - "The Nature Boy" Ric Flair this!!!!!!!! as for now..... pac would still be p4p#1 in my book. they both need to fight each other to settle up..... pac is ahead.. but if floyd manhandle sugar ass's the gap will not be as bigger as it is right now....

Nope. Floyd must take the title from the p4p champ himself. too right he would have to....

I like both fighters and would consider myself unbiased. I don't think Floyd can overtake Manny until maybe the next fight after these unless Manny loses this one with a Floyd win. But to be honest I just hope they do fight next after this and that will settle #1 p4p for sure. To be honest I have a feeling both Manny and Floyd will come through, but both will be tough tough fights for them. Either way at least one good thing is we have two cracking fights lined up and I can't wait for both of them!

They don't change. There won't be a change until Pac retires or loses.

lol aright.. Roy Jones got knocked out twice and lost on a decision, which he was on a losing streak before Floyd took over p4p in 05. Floyd obviously was the best boxer even more over Tarver after what he did to Jones. If they both win then.. it's STILLLLL THE BEST BOXER IN WORLLDDDDDDD MANNY! PACMAN! PACQUIIIIAAAOOOOOO just like Michael Buffer would. i know bout roy but this guy was sayin in order to take top spot floyd has to beat pac which he doesnt if pac keeps fightin this kinda opposition and floyd fighten the caliber of fighters hes taken on hes gonna move up on p4p list

I believe so, yes. Margo's both handwraps was still there during post fight interview with kellerman. It looked really tight and no way of telling whether its loaded or not.

Nope. Floyd must take the title from the p4p champ himself. Agreed if they both win i think Pac still deserves P4P # 1 ranking.........floyd needs to whip Pac for it....... they could bill it like this: p4p SUPREMACY

I believe so, yes.

Can we post links here?

But watch the end of the fight. Like 10 people raise his hand in the air. Think about it, wouldn't they have felt it? The ref, at the very least, could feel such a significant difference. And he took the gloves off. It just doesn't seem like something a cheater would do. He shouldn't get the benefit of the doubt, obviously, but from what I've seen, it doesn't look like he was cheating for that fight. I have got to see that. Maybe i can find that fight at youtube.

But watch the end of the fight. Like 10 people raise his hand in the air. Think about it, wouldn't they have felt it? The ref, at the very least, could feel such a significant difference. And he took the gloves off. It just doesn't seem like something a cheater would do. He shouldn't get the benefit of the doubt, obviously, but from what I've seen, it doesn't look like he was cheating for that fight.

Look, I think Margo is as awful as anyone after the Shane incident. But after the Cotto fight, he takes his gloves off immediately. Would you do that if you had cement in your gloves? Probably not. Not only that, someone grabs his hand and lifts it. There is no way they wouldn't have felt that plaster in his wraps. Bottomline is, he didn't cheat against Cotto. Cotto just got the shit kicked out of him. Of course there wasn't the same accumulation against Mosley - Mosley was beating the sense out of Margarito all night. It was a one-sided beatdown. Cotto was on the run all night and getting beat to a pulp. That's why his face was all ****ed up, not because of any plaster. That being said, he still took a beating and it somewhat lessens the value of the win for Pacquiao. I say Manny is holding onto the top spot by the skin of his teeth - if he doesn't either KO Clottey or win a one-sided UD and Floyd outpoints Shane, then he gets the P4P title. Cotto was winning the early rounds. It wasn't like cotto slowed down after 3 or 4 round. He started showing all these bumps and swelling after seven. Clearly to me, the plaster was already hard. He did not have to hit cotto hard. He just had to touch him and blood gushingout of cotto. You know what,no need to even talk about it.We will never know. The bad thing for margo, he got caught.

even tho floyd is fighting the better fighter, DOES NOT make him the better fighter. if floyd wants the crown back, he's going to have beat the king.

LOL fukin pac idiots p4p belt is not won by beatin the guy lol if u remember for most the 90s roy jones was considered the p4p best followed by floyd so maybe i missed it when floyd beat roy p4p is somethin obtained by beatin the best and after these fights both wininng floyd will have beat the better opposition hed def take a step above pac lol aright.. Roy Jones got knocked out twice and lost on a decision, which he was on a losing streak before Floyd took over p4p in 05. Floyd obviously was the best boxer even more over Tarver after what he did to Jones. If they both win then.. it's STILLLLL THE BEST BOXER IN WORLLDDDDDDD MANNY! PACMAN! PACQUIIIIAAAOOOOOO just like Michael Buffer would.

If mayweather and pacman both win do you think the rankings will change ? would you change them ? Pacquiao already won the fighter of the decade award, which seals his P4P-1 rating even if both wins. Moreover, Mosley, if he loses this fight, could be rated as an old, washed up and past-prime fighter. This would not improve FLoyd`s rating much. However, Floyd, as another newly crowned ww champ, would result in a world-wide clamor for a unification showdown with the Pacman to settle all titles once and for all.