Should Calzaghe come out of retirement to build up his legacy?

He won't come back, everything to lose, not much to gain, unless he loses all his £.

Yes, he should come back. His talent and style don't match his credentials. He didn't do shit in between Eubank and Lacy.

Calzaghe still has a lot left in the tank and I thought he retired prematurely. I'd like to see him come out of retirement towards the end of the Super 6 tourney fight a tuneup and then fight the winner... this one :D If he came back and defeated Dawson, Froch, Ward and Pascal, his haters would still say his resume is no good. So I hope he has a happy retirement! :) defenetily, his resume still wont be good with Abraham missing.

yeah if joe comes out and fights someone meaningful...he'll be put on his neck and enzo will have a heart attack...

He will not come out of retirement because of the fact there is good competiton out there All of these guys in the super 6 are going to lose at least once and Joe Wussy Calzaghe is gonna claim how none of them went undefeated and how much better he is of course Joe would never have entered a tournament like this one he should just stay put and enjoy his sweet life I agree... I heard that Sven Ottke wants a piece of his sweet a$$ as well... stay retired Joe... only a$$ whoopings will await you

He will not come out of retirement because of the fact there is good competiton out there All of these guys in the super 6 are going to lose at least once and Joe Wussy Calzaghe is gonna claim how none of them went undefeated and how much better he is of course Joe would never have entered a tournament like this one he should just stay put and enjoy his sweet life Joe Cal cracks me up at times, the dudes ego is worst than Floyd.... Floyd's act is a persona, Joe is really stuck on himself.

na he is way past his prime cant even punch anymore he cleared up the SMW division,moved up to LHW to beat the no.1 guy and take his ring title then finished it off by beating up roy jones nothing left to prove

If his love ain't in the sport and he doesn't have that drive anymore, he should stay out. So it would all depend.

No, he's been retired for over a year now. Floyd was retired for 2. Vitali was retired for 4.

If he came back and defeated Dawson, Froch, Ward and Pascal, his haters would still say his resume is no good. So I hope he has a happy retirement! :) Like he has come close to testing that theory. Ward/Dawson are more technically skilled than any fighter Calzaghe has been in the ring with who are not too old.

Yes he does need to come out of retirement if he wants his resume to not be a joke. But if he is financially set and he doesn't give a shit about what the fans want or the quality of his past opposition, then the douche should stay in retirement. I think Kessler might lose to Froch too. Calzaghe would handle Froch, which goes to show you that Calzaghe's talent is a lot better than his courage.

Its not hard if you retire after fighting two old ass fighters. Just saying. A Floyd fan at his best,no shame huh!!How in the world is a Floyd fan gonna have the nerve to talk about anyone's resume,How??U gotta be shameless I guess,wow!!:bigeyes::poke::banghead::stupid:

bok! bok! bok! http://i259.photobucket.com/albums/hh284/boojee12/mosley.jpg http://i259.photobucket.com/albums/hh284/boojee12/mayweathercrying.jpg

bok! bok! bok! but..but...but..."we played basketball together" http://i259.photobucket.com/albums/hh284/boojee12/chickenfloyd.jpg http://i259.photobucket.com/albums/hh284/boojee12/marg_g_mosley_576.jpg Wrong thread squinty eyed retard.

Its not hard if you retire after fighting two old ass fighters. Just saying. Hopkins still had something left. Of course Jones was completely shot. Still Joe wasn't exactly a spring chicken himself. No. It's a good call. I hate that Hopkins, Jones, Holyfield and others are still fighting when they really should be lying on the beach.

bok! bok! bok! but..but...but..."we played basketball together" http://i259.photobucket.com/albums/hh284/boojee12/chickenfloyd.jpg http://i259.photobucket.com/albums/hh284/boojee12/marg_g_mosley_576.jpg

Id like him to come back and get flattened, i hate the prick! If he was smart he'd have fought Froch who gave him mad shit and the UK public wanted him to fight, as he would tear the Cobra a new one with some ease! IF he makes a comeback the winner of the Super Six would be a good oppenent

No. He has set a rare example of a boxer retirering while on top. Its not hard if you retire after fighting two old ass fighters. Just saying.

No. He has set a rare example of a boxer retirering while on top.

dont change the topic. seems like Floyd is scared to Mosley bok! bok! bok! http://i259.photobucket.com/albums/hh284/boojee12/chickenfloyd.jpg