Mosley's win over Margacheato is overrated.

nah it's not overrated, mosley was on his way out, marg was ontop of the world styles make fights, but that doesn't mean you should take away from mosleys victory, because it was a great feat

the moral of the story is shane beat the piss out that boy

Mosley's win over Margacheato is overrated. Margacheato had just been caught cheating moments earlier so his game was WAY OFF that night. Margacheato's mind must have been a hellava mess throughout that whole fight. A win is still a win.

Like they say, it's 50% physical and 50% mental. Margarito's mindset would have been completely farked going into the fight.

Xactly! I think the win is overrated because mentally Margarito was GONE. ...........................

Very good observation. If the Berto fight happened first before Pbf, we could have a better gauge of Mosley now and how he could cope with Pbf.

Thats not Shanes fault. I didn't say it was Shane's fault.

I think the win is overrated because mentally Margarito was GONE. Thats not Shanes fault.

I think the win is overrated because mentally Margarito was GONE.

It is kind of overrated and I am sure that effected him that night but Shane killed him so I have a hard time seeing Margarito ever really messing with Shane. He might have not got taken out and he might have been stronger down the streach but I do not think he could beat Shane as Shane is tough enough and has enough mental toughness to always get to the end with him. Also while Mosley is not some great technical boxer he is still superior to Margarito so aslong as Shane is able to go the full 12 he should be able to box his way to a decision. It is kind of over rated though as Shane was so impressive it is hard to not over rate him on that night.

overrated because he beat margarito who for once wasnt using plaster of paris in his wraps...

Mosley's win over Margacheato is overrated. Margacheato had just been caught cheating moments earlier so his game was WAY OFF that night. Margacheato's mind must have been a hellava mess throughout that whole fight. IMO, it was slightly overrated not because of those reason. I think Mosley beats Marg anytime, with/without plaster. I think Marg stalking style is tailor made for Mosley. He just stands in front on him even when Mosley is already dishing bombs and clinching so Marg can't unleash his combos. If the Berto fight happened first before Pbf, we could have a better gauge of Mosley now and how he could cope with Pbf. I have Pbf winning this 9-3 unless maybe 24/7 could convince me otherwise. :D

I think Margarito lost on purpose to make penance for his crimes. I agree that Mosleys win over Margarito is questionable. LMAO are you serious... So I'ma take blows to the head on purpose, get knocked down once, and get knocked OUT when I could of quit after the first knock down just to make up for my crime which til this day says hes innocent... hmmmm GOOD PLAN on Margaritos stand, keep em coming you seem to know everything behind the scenes

I think Margarito lost on purpose to make penance for his crimes. I agree that Mosleys win over Margarito is questionable.

Not to mention that Margarito is a walking punching bag. You don't necessarily need the greatest technical boxing skill to beat him. A walking punching bag correct but he's never been knocked out before and that says alot for Mosleys power

Mosley's win over Margacheato is overrated. Margacheato had just been caught cheating moments earlier so his game was WAY OFF that night. Margacheato's mind must have been a hellava mess throughout that whole fight. Not to mention that Margarito is a walking punching bag. You don't necessarily need the greatest technical boxing skill to beat him.

Yah whatever. It is a point which can facilitate discussion, Capiche??? So do you have anything worthwhile to contribute? No pun intended bud. However, I do not think that Sugar's win over Marg is overrated. Shane is a man on a mission, Marg with or without plaster was going to get a good ol' whooping.:boxing:

I dont care where Margs mind was. Shane knocked it to row 12. :boxing: damn sure did LMAO

Well thank you for an actual valid response. I dont care where Margs mind was. Shane knocked it to row 12.

Yah whatever. It is a point which can facilitate discussion, Capiche??? So do you have anything worthwhile to contribute? I dont care where Margs mind was. Shane knocked it to row 12.