Do you think Cotto should rematch Margarito without his weapons?

It's really whether he'd be willing to fight differently or not. I remember an interview after the fight where he insisted he wouldn't clinch, which is exactly what you need to do to beat Margarito. Really that's the only difference between what Cotto and Mosley did as far as I can see. Mosley used effective clinching to keep Margarito from hitting him, Cotto let him swing away. So if Cotto would be willing to use a bit more strategy he probably wins easy and should take the fight. If he insists on being ummm, manly and not clinching, then he'll probably get another beatdown unless Margarito has no chin left (a definite possibility).

god knows I like Cotto way way way more than Marg......but Marg has Cotto's number IMO......why does the fact that Cotto couldn't hurt Marg seems to get left outta that fight's debate?!?.....Cotto has been in too many wars, another fight with Marg will mean ANOTHER war......I wouldn't advise Cotto to take this fight if I was in charge of his match making :boxing:

if he changes corners and has at least 2 fights first to build confidence and get used to a new trainer i think i would welcome a rematch with open arms

Do you think after Cotto beats Foreman he should fight Margarito? No. Why give him the payday? Margarito should be banned anyway.

I don't see this fight playing out any differently. might not. but part 1 was one of the best fights i've ever seen. i'd love to see a part 2.

a rematch would be great. I don't see this fight playing out any differently.

a rematch would be great.