How can Floyd Jr be at top 5-7 WW?

Cotto vs Margocheato Margocheato vs Mosley Mosley vs Cotto Clottey Vs Margocheato Clottey vs Cotto Pacquaio vs Cotto P-will Vs Margocheato Soon Pacquaio Vs Clottey Berto Vs Mosley You can even add Berto vs Collazo And the name Missing is Floyd jr. He last 2 fight were JMM a LW and Ricky Hatton a JWW. Well hatton only had one fight at welter and he won a belt from collazo and even knocked him down. You claim Collazo as a top 10 so surely ricky has to count as a top ten welter too, maybe not a top 5 but certainly a top ten. He also beat Oscar who was a 154 beltholder, that has to count for something. So his last 4 fights he beat the lineal ww champ, a 154 pound champ, an undefeated 140 champ who had fought and beat a top 10 ww while winning a belt at ww, and beat a top 5 p4p fighter who moved up too much in weight as a tune up after a long layoff. If Pac had KO'd Floyd would you not mention his name as another elite top 5 ww fighter that pac had beaten?

In terms of pure talent, he is top 10.

If you have to ask a dumb question like this. You must be a pactard that just discovered boxing. "peeleft: I bet I been watching boxing longer then you..

exactly, i don't even know why he is #2 in the pound-for-pound list ?!! He's been a welterweight for few years now and he doesn't have any of the elite welters on his resume (no williams, margo, cotto, mosley, collazo, cintron, berto, and now not even pacquiao) he had jmm (a lightweight) and hatton (a junior welter) as his last two fights! Is this pound-for-pound worthy at all ??? how bout dlh at 154??

Exactly, I don't even know why he is #2 in the Pound-for-pound list ?!! He's been a welterweight for few years now and he doesn't have any of the elite welters on his resume (no Williams, Margo, Cotto, Mosley, Collazo, Cintron, Berto, and now not even Pacquiao) He had JMM (a lightweight) and Hatton (a junior welter) as his last two fights! Is this pound-for-pound worthy at all ??? I agree.....

Cotto vs Margocheato Margocheato vs Mosley Mosley vs Cotto Clottey Vs Margocheato Clottey vs Cotto Pacquaio vs Cotto P-will Vs Margocheato Soon Pacquaio Vs Clottey Berto Vs Mosley You can even add Berto vs Collazo And the name Missing is Floyd jr. He last 2 fight were JMM a LW and Ricky Hatton a JWW. the same way hopkins is ranked #1 at LHW, even tho the last true LHW contender or champion he fought was tarver in 2006! **** outta here.... :nonono:

maybe because he was the last undisputed welterweight champion the real question is what makes Clottey top 5 as some of the Pacfans say? Any respectable boxing fan would have Clottey in the top at least 7. He's at least 5 in my book, he's had tough tough fights with all the top guys.

mayweather-baldomir-judah-spinks-mayorga-forrest-mosley-de la hoya.. etc thats how the lineal WW championship has been passed in recent years. not to mention when judah beat spinks it was for the IBF, WBC and WBA titles. UNDISPUTED! u know what that means? u can dismiss him as chicken dance judah if u want to but the fact remains he and only he was the number one WW in the world. in fact he was the last undisputed WW champion since baldomir vacated some belts due to money. and it was those then paper titles that guys like cotto picked up. judah was the man back then, thats a fact. strange how none of those guys fought the guy who was ranked number 1 at welterweight for 5 years. it's almost like they were ducking him...........well i hope they enjoyed their lil party amongst themselves.

Based on talent? He's #1. Based on accomplishments at WW over the past 2 years? No. Since he was retired for 21 months and came back to fight a lightweight. Really no point to this thread besides attracting attention to yourself. How can you say he #1 based on Talent when he fought no one?

Chickendance Judah? Come on :alcoholic mayweather-baldomir-judah-spinks-mayorga-forrest-mosley-de la hoya.. etc thats how the lineal WW championship has been passed in recent years. not to mention when judah beat spinks it was for the IBF, WBC and WBA titles. UNDISPUTED! u know what that means? u can dismiss him as chicken dance judah if u want to but the fact remains he and only he was the number one WW in the world. in fact he was the last undisputed WW champion since baldomir vacated some belts due to money. and it was those then paper titles that guys like cotto picked up. judah was the man back then, thats a fact.

how come Floyd fans are ducking my post.. Only Dominicano Soy came in here. and he agrees..

maybe because he was the last undisputed welterweight champion the real question is what makes Clottey top 5 as some of the Pacfans say?

forget clottey, baldomir beat judah. now judah has fell of, but then he had just beat spinks for the WBC, WBA, IBF and Ring Mag titles. he was the universally recognized WW champion of the world, baldy beat him it was a fluke. but floyd made sure to prove who was the man by beating both. he only properly defended his title once against hatton. and then retired and hasnt done shit since, but he does deserve top be a top 5 WW based on beating the two top WWs even if it was a while ago. Chickendance Judah? Come on :alcoholic

He's not a top 10 anything. He's a WW that fights Lightweights and washed up welterweights, nothing more.

Mayweather did "destroy" Baldomir and Baldomir according to one Flomo "destroyed" Clottey. :439: forget clottey, baldomir beat judah. now judah has fell of, but then he had just beat spinks for the WBC, WBA, IBF and Ring Mag titles. he was the universally recognized WW champion of the world, baldy beat him it was a fluke. but floyd made sure to prove who was the man by beating both. he only properly defended his title once against hatton. and then retired and hasnt done shit since, but he does deserve top be a top 5 WW based on beating the two top WWs even if it was a while ago.

What's up Dominicano,U ok!??:eek: I've said that for a while. He was out for almost 2 years.

where are they now? carlos baldomir-lost his welterweight crown to floyd mayweather in a stunningly boring display of cowardice and impotence. and then he lost every fight since then. baldomir says he would like to challenge reggie strickland's record of most losses by a professional boxer. is now residing in argentina with his wife and 16 children selling carpet samples. when he tells people he was the welterweight champ they just point and laugh.

Cotto vs Margocheato Margocheato vs Mosley Mosley vs Cotto Clottey Vs Margocheato Clottey vs Cotto Pacquaio vs Cotto P-will Vs Margocheato Soon Pacquaio Vs Clottey Berto Vs Mosley You can even add Berto vs Collazo And the name Missing is Floyd jr. He last 2 fight were JMM a LW and Ricky Hatton a JWW. people have a way of taking potential or speculation as fact.

Mayweather did "destroy" Baldomir and Baldomir according to one Flomo "destroyed" Clottey. :439:

He isn't in my opinion. What's up Dominicano,U ok!??:eek: