OShaquieFosterShakurStevenson

Victorious O’Shaquie Fosters calls for showdown with Shakur Stevenson

Declan Warrington

•15h ago•12 Comments

FosterFord01

Masterful O’Shaquie Foster tames Raymond Ford to retain WBC 130lbs title

Declan Warrington

•23h ago•5 Comments

Dmitry

Dmitry Bivol dominates overmatched Michael Eifert, makes it look all too easy

•1d ago•7 Comments

FosterFordWeighIn01

Eddie Hearn anticipates Texan launchpad for Raymond Ford

Declan Warrington

•1d ago•Read more

Benavidez_Mikaelian copy

WBC to Noel Mikaelian: Fight David Benavidez next, or else

•2d ago•3 Comments

Opetaia_Mikaelian

Jai Opetaia, Noel Mikaelian finalizing Ring cruiserweight showdown

•2d ago•4 Comments

Rico Verhoeven [right] clouts Oleksandr Usyk in Egypt on May 23, 2026

The Beltline: Kickboxer Rico Verhoeven becomes the poster boy for boxing’s WTF era

•2d ago•1 Comment

O'Shaquie Foster raises a glove following his December 2025 victory over Stephen Fulton.

‘Special’ O’Shaquie Foster is the smartest fighter Bobby Benton has trained

Declan Warrington

•3d ago•1 Comment

Rico Verhoeven at the London press conference for his fight against Oleksandr Usyk. (April 14, 2026)

Rico Verhoeven happy to take on all-comers at heavyweight - with one exception

•3d ago•5 Comments

Gervonta Davis looks up at a person speaking at a microphone during a press conference on September 22, 2025, for Davis' exhibition match with Jake Paul.

Tank in Trouble: Arrest warrant issued for Gervonta 'Tank' Davis

•4d ago•11 Comments

Vasiliy Lomachneko

Vasiliy Lomachenko wants Charly Suarez for comeback, official says

•4d ago•4 Comments

International Boxing Hall of Fame inductee Holly Holm waves at a December 2025 press conference, days ahead of her first boxing match in years.

Holly Holm hopes to ride Stephanie Han rematch to showdowns with Ronda Rousey, Katie Taylor

•4d ago•1 Comment

O'Shaquie Foster (left) and Raymond Ford face off at the press conference. (April 24, 2026)

‘Way better’ Raymond Ford plays down O’Shaquie Foster’s résumé

Declan Warrington

•5d ago•3 Comments

Agit Kabayel celebrates his February 2025 victory over Zhilei Zhang.

WBC order for Oleksandr Usyk-Agit Kabayel to be next remains

•5d ago•1 Comment

Rico Verhoeven, with coach Peter Fury, is announced to the crowd ahead of his fight with Oleksandr Usyk

'If Oleksandr Usyk didn't take Rico Verhoeven seriously he would have been stopped'

•5d ago•9 Comments

Mark Lyson steps in to stop the fight with Verhoeven on the ropes and Usyk set to celebrate

Oleksandr Usyk-Rico Verhoeven: Peter Fury confronts and then forgives the referee on flight home

BoxingScene Staff

•6d ago•21 Comments

Frank Warren at the press conference for Fabio Wardley-Daniel Dubois. (May 7, 2026)

Frank Warren: Oleksandr Usyk must be stripped if Rico Verhoeven rematch comes next

BoxingScene Staff

•6d ago•16 Comments

Oleksandr Usyk has his hand held aloft by Mark Lyson having defeated Rico Verhoeven

Boxing owes it to Rico Verhoeven to ensure Oleksandr Usyk rematch happens

•1w ago•17 Comments

Oleksandr Usyk, pictured after his victory over Rico Verhoeven

Oleksandr Usyk found out

•1w ago•21 Comments

Rico Verhoeven fires a left at Oleksandr Usyk

Sphinx Jinx: Oleksandr Usyk dodges a bullet to score late stoppage of Rico Verhoeven

•1w ago•54 Comments

Oleksandr Usyk and Rico Verhoeven take to the scales in Egypt

Oleksandr Usyk-Rico Verhoeven preview: Who wins and how?

•1w ago•7 Comments

Oleksandr Usyk and Rico Verhoeven get ready for battle in May 2026 in Egypt

Oleksandr Usyk-Rico Verhoeven weigh-in: Usyk 233.3lbs; Verhoeven 258.7lbs

BoxingScene Staff

•1w ago•9 Comments

Agit Kabayel sits down for an interview.

Agit Kabayel says Oleksandr Usyk ‘must fight me next’

•1w ago•23 Comments

Oleksandr Usyk plays for the camera in April 2026

Oleksandr Usyk: 'Three more fights... When I say I'm retired, I won't be back'

BoxingScene Staff

•1w ago•36 Comments

Richard Torrez Jnr stands in the ring during his boxing match with Tomas Salek on November 15, 2025.

Richard Torrez Jnr ventures a world away to discover if he's world-class

•1w ago•36 Comments

Ryan Garcia Photo:Geoffrey Knott/Matchroom

Ryan Garcia tells Jimmy Fallon that Conor Benn is next

•1w ago•15 Comments

Naoya Inoue 12272025

Naoya Inoue-Jesse 'Bam' Rodriguez in Japan? 'Without a shadow of a doubt'

•1w ago•3 Comments

Oleksandr Usyk takes the fight to Anthony Joshua at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium in 2021

Oleksandr Usyk-Anthony Joshua III not out of the question, says Eddie Hearn

•2w ago•29 Comments

Filip Hrgovic clatters Dave Allen with a right shortly before the end of their May 16 contest

Filip Hrgovic blasts through Dave Allen, sets up Moses Itauma showdown

•2w ago•35 Comments

Lawrence Okolie makes his way to the ring in 2025

Lawrence Okolie: ‘I did not cheat, this is very clear cut’

Declan Warrington

•2w ago•12 Comments

Judging Hall of Shame. | BoxingScene Community

Back to Community

Judging Hall of Shame.

Philfy16y ago

Is 2009 the year of the dodgy judge? It certainly seems that way. Poor judging has changed the outcome of fights and made a mockery of the sport. Let us now turn our attention to the very judges who ruin a good fight with their shameful scorecards. Nominations: Pierre Benoist has earned his rightful place in the judging hall of shame with a ludicrous 119-110 scorecard in the fight between Paul Williams and Sergio Martinez. Gale van Hoy from the Juan Diaz v Paulie Malignaggi fight. This moron scored a close bout 118-110 to Diaz in a fight that Malignaggi predicted he would be screwed over in. Alan Davis: After Ali Funeka dishes out a beating to Joan Guzman, this judge has the gall to score the bout a draw, robbing Funeka of righful victory. Benoit Roussel in a masterful display of judging incompetence also robs Ali Funeka of victory by scoring that same fight 114-114. Mike Fitzgerald in his debut as a boxing judge scored a fight 116-112 to Vincente Escobedo. Fortunately the other judges had more sense to score it favorably for Katsidis in a deserved win. Honourable mentions also go to these judges: Massimo Barrovecchio raised eyebrows by gifting Froch a 115-112 advantage over Andre Dirrell in a close fight that Dirrell won comfortably by at least 2 rounds. Daniel Van de Wiele as above.

Comments (1)

Is 2009 the year of the dodgy judge? It certainly seems that way. Poor judging has changed the outcome of fights and made a mockery of the sport. Let us now turn our attention to the very judges who ruin a good fight with their shameful scorecards. Nominations: Pierre Benoist has earned his rightful place in the judging hall of shame with a ludicrous 119-110 scorecard in the fight between Paul Williams and Sergio Martinez. Gale van Hoy from the Juan Diaz v Paulie Malignaggi fight. This moron scored a close bout 118-110 to Diaz in a fight that Malignaggi predicted he would be screwed over in. Alan Davis: After Ali Funeka dishes out a beating to Joan Guzman, this judge has the gall to score the bout a draw, robbing Funeka of righful victory. Benoit Roussel in a masterful display of judging incompetence also robs Ali Funeka of victory by scoring that same fight 114-114. Mike Fitzgerald in his debut as a boxing judge scored a fight 116-112 to Vincente Escobedo. Fortunately the other judges had more sense to score it favorably for Katsidis in a deserved win. Honourable mentions also go to these judges: Massimo Barrovecchio raised eyebrows by gifting Froch a 115-112 advantage over Andre Dirrell in a close fight that Dirrell won comfortably by at least 2 rounds. Daniel Van de Wiele as above. Very nice thread. I agree with everything except that the honorable mention was atleast debatable. The other judging was not. All the other judging was so outrageous that said judges should be investigated and banned from judging.

16y ago