It was a close fight!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

this is the file of judge pierre benoist. Looking at his previous fights that he scored, they were more consistent. So i don't know what he saw with this fight. http://boxrec.com/list_bouts.php?human_id=402009&cat=judge

Great fight close 1!!119-110 was garbage,they should do it again,I had it 7 rounds to 5,Punisher,but I wouldn't say a draw was a crazy score!!

I had all the rounds pretty close... but PW's first round kd of sergio was more of a slip, and sergio rocked Pdub in his kd.. So, if Pwill weren't the favored fighter and it was actually equal grounds, Martinez should have got the decision, by a hair. But I don't call this a robbery either. except for that 119-110 card

I had it a draw

where in the world did this judge pierre benoist come from? 119-110?

I had Martinez winning 118-111

Martinez shoulv'ed won the fight... 119-110 WTF....

This is how it's a robbery. If you think that a judge could have been paid off to give the fight to someone regardless of how it played out, that makes it a robbery. It taints the fight. It takes away the possibility of the fight being fairly contested. He wouldn't have had a fair shake, regardless. That makes it a robbery. Regardless of if it was close or the right man won.

I probably would have scored it a draw. If Martinez didn't go down in the first, I would have probably given him the win. It was a very close fight though, and anyone watching could have scored it either way. 119-110 is obviously a joke of a score, but either way, Paul Williams won according to the judges. If he scored it 115-113 instead, everyone would just shrug their shoulders and agree that it was a close fight.

i thought it was a draw. 119-110 = robbery.

bump bump bump