It was a classical fight,dnt desrespect it by calling it a robbery

119-110 makes it a robbery... that judge was bought off by goosen or haymon.

why the hell were all judges americans?

Just because a stupid ass blind judge scored it 119-110 doesnt make the DEICISION A ROBBERY,because one judge had it even,and the other paper thin close,so the deicision wasnt a robbery,not even close,one judge just happened to piss everybody off You're obviously too stupid to understand the context.

What makes the fight a robbery isn't the fact that it was close fight scored for one guy; it's a robbery because it was a single round from being a majority draw instead of a 119-110 raping. Either guy could've been the winner, but that scoring is that unqualified judge's attempt to marr something beautiful. All that said the greatness of this fight shouldn't be tarnished by the awful scoring, but we, the boxing public, must do our part to hold this judge accountable. And part of that means calling attention to the scoring, if that means using the word robbery, then that's a burden this fight will have to bear for a while. I'm reminded of Barrera V Morales the first time. Larry Merchant went nuts after the fight saying Barrera should not win this fight by a 2 point round because that was no knockdown! Then he complained when Barrera lost. The point of that is that regardless of the immediate reaction to the scoring, the beauty of the fight itself willl endure long after people forget that nuances decided things in an unpopular direction at the time. Holyfield V Lewis 1 was similar (a draw are you serious?!)

Oh..and if anything,Sergio's stock has just risen up majorly,so has PWills

Funeka-Guzman was a robbery,shit,that was worser then daylight robbery,but this wasnt,it was a great close fight

No robbery. The last judge is a total incompetent (there were four clear rounds to Martinez IMHO) and should never be employed again, but in the end another 115-113 would have had exactly the same result.

When i heard 119-110 I thought it was crazy but HAD to be in favor of Martinez. Because I thought Martinez won more of the rounds CLEARLY, especially the first couple. So I figured no way he only won 1, and they gave all the close ones to him, which is still crazy. I just ....i dunno....fuk off man lol. :grumble:

Great great fight,I think Martinez won, but it was too close to argue, could have gone either way. Props to Martinez for stepping up to the plate.

this was a great fight. shout out to Martinez for coming to. He did what I thought he would do. I thought PW eeked out a 2rd W but I wouldnt have been screaming robbery if it went the other way. This was an exciting fight and thats the reason I like PW. I always get my money's worth each time he laces them up. They need to go ahead and fight for the 154 title next. I like martinez at 154 though. But Fuk it, we get fireworks and thats all that matters.

119 makes it a robbery. Just because a stupid ass blind judge scored it 119-110 doesnt make the DEICISION A ROBBERY,because one judge had it even,and the other paper thin close,so the deicision wasnt a robbery,not even close,one judge just happened to piss everybody off

Closest fight I have ever seen. There is not a single round in that fight that wasn't a toss up.

agreed great fight ...could of gone either way 115-113 for either fighter depends on what you base your scoring on williams pressed the fight and made the fight the action packed fight it was but martinez hurt him alot more than williams hurt him and he def. landed the harder cleaner punches, i has martinez winning the fight .....either way 119-110 should be investigated scores like this is what gives boxing a bad name ..

119 makes it a robbery. yep, it really does.

Sorry bishop, on NSB when a judge does something that crazy people call it a robbery... I thought Sergio won a close fight...cudda gave it to Paul

that judge was payed off... I thought it was a draw but 119-110 is garbage.

119 makes it a robbery.

robbery, that judge was payed off Did you score it?

Great post, I had it close for Williams but the fight was amazing. 119-110 is a disgrace but the fight was not a robbery.

Could have gone either way. 115-113 for either fighter wouldnt have suprised me I think I honestly threw up in my mouth a bit when I heard 119-110