So Manny is still higher than Floyd even if??

It doesnt matter if Pac fought apes his whole career it doesnt mean a damn thing when Floyd Mayweather Jr. is starring at you across the ring....most people Floyd fight realize right there that there in aginst a ukking defensive machine who fights PERFECTLY.....Mayweather reminds me of the last level bosses in the fighting video games...lol. Is there any point in this post? Or is it clearly the heavily biased, nonsensical, fact lacking drivel that it appears to be?

Mayweather definitely fought a much more game Oscar De LeHoya and Ricky Hatton no??? Did I not just say Floyd fought a much more game Oscar De La Hoya? Hatton? Floyd fought him above his natural weight. Not that I'll use that excuse ; Hatton is just shit. A win over him for fighters the caliber of Manny and Floyd is almost an embarassment. That's how horrible he is.

even if floyd beats manny? manny has 5 belts in 5 weight classes floyd has 6 belts in 5 weight classes is this pure hate keeping floyd from being ranked higher in your eyes if he were to beat manny when they fight? I know you're a floyd hater you're always making floyd look bad. Please stop insulting mayweather for telling lies.

Manniy is a Champ, Floyd is Joke! Until he fights and beat Mosley and Manny... He will never have a Legacy greater than Manny.

Floyd cannot take away what Pac has accomplished.

great post as usual bringer sir... and skills are really subjective... boxing is not diving or gymnastics... Indeed. Especially the bolded. Solid point, my man. :fing02:

Dont try to act like Pacs win over Oscar was anything significant. It was just another name/ There was never any threat there. Same with a shot Morales ( 3rd fght).......Diaz......Larios. See what I did there. Floyd's win over Oscar > Manny's win over Oscar Manny's win over Hatton > Floyd's win over Hatton Those two cancel one another out. That leaves Manny with MarcoX2, Erik X2, Juan Manuel X2, and Cotto. And Floyd with CastilloX2, Corrales, Hernandez, and a blown up Marquez. I'd say Barrera and Morales are equal to Corrales and Castillo, in terms of risk and reward. Manny definitely fought a much more game Juan manuel Marquez than Floyd did by fighting him at Welterweight. That leaves Hernandez vs. Cotto. Manny's accomplishments are beating Floyd's right now bro, face it. 7 titles in 7 weight divisions says it all.

Pac has beaten JMM....Barerra, Morales, Cotto, Oscar and Hatton. Floyd has beaten JMM, Judah, Hernandez, Corralles, Castillo, Oscar, and Hatton, and then Pacman. Floyd would be greater. Floyd kayod Hatton - Pacquiao annihilated him Floyd SDd DLH - Pacquiao annihilated him (before you mention 'weight-drained' Pac was a heavy underdog) Floyd wouldn't fight Cotto - Pacquiao annihilated him Pac fought Marquez at his optimum weight and fought in two competitive and exciting fights - MM bullied him BTW way MMs a great fighter but ppl gota giv Pac his props

You're confusing skill with accomplishment, my brother. On a pure skill level ; there's no question that Floyd mayweather Jr. is far beyond Manny Pacquiao on the field of skill level. But on an accomplishment level ; Manny is ranking above Floyd, currently. In everybody's mind. Skill doesn't determine your legacy ; accomplishments do. Bennie Briscoe was one of the most skilled Middleweights of All Time, in my opinion. But he never won a World title. Same goes with Packey McFarland at Lightweight. great post as usual bringer sir... and skills are really subjective... boxing is not diving or gymnastics...

Lets face it Pac fans, if Pac loses to Floyd he will not go down as being greater than Floyd in history. The question of how could Pac be greater than Floyd if he lost to Floyd will always come up. I think Pac has been 20 times more entertaining than Floyd, but when it comes to skills, Floyd takes the cake. You're confusing skill with accomplishment, my brother. On a pure skill level ; there's no question that Floyd mayweather Jr. is far beyond Manny Pacquiao on the field of skill level. But on an accomplishment level ; Manny is ranking above Floyd, currently. In everybody's mind. Skill doesn't determine your legacy ; accomplishments do. Bennie Briscoe was one of the most skilled Middleweights of All Time, in my opinion. But he never won a World title. Same goes with Packey McFarland at Lightweight.

Lets face it Pac fans, if Pac loses to Floyd he will not go down as being greater than Floyd in history. The question of how could Pac be greater than Floyd if he lost to Floyd will always come up. I think Pac has been 20 times more entertaining than Floyd, but when it comes to skills, Floyd takes the cake. As it stands Manny could retire tommorrow and still have a better resume than Floyd. His legacy is cemented, his win over Cotto was just the icing.

Lets face it Pac fans, if Pac loses to Floyd he will not go down as being greater than Floyd in history. The question of how could Pac be greater than Floyd if he lost to Floyd will always come up. I think Pac has been 20 times more entertaining than Floyd, but when it comes to skills, Floyd takes the cake.

Pac has beaten JMM....Barerra, Morales, Cotto, Oscar and Hatton. Floyd has beaten JMM, Judah, Hernandez, Corralles, Castillo, Oscar, and Hatton, and then Pacman. Floyd would be greater. Don't even try to act like Floyd's win over Marquez was anything significant. It was just another name. There was never any threat there. Same with Judah. And Baldomir. And Gatti. And Mitchell. And Bruseles.

i dont count ibo/nabf belts you must not count ring belts too. makes sense. don't count his wins against the #1 guy at 126 and 140 when he beat them.

i dont count ibo/nabf belts I don't either. 147 - WBO 140 - Ring 135 - WBC 130 - WBC/Ring 126 - Ring 122 - IBF 112 - WBC/Lineal

Manny has 7 belts, in 7 weightclasses, and an overall better record than Floyd does. The act of beating Pacquiao does not, in turn, make Mayweather better than him on paper. It's a nice accomplishment, and likely the best of his career ; but that alone is not enough to propel him over Pacquiao on any "ATG" list. He'd need another good "name" or two because his record is not on par with Manny's as of right now. Why is this so hard to understand?

yes, it's pretty obvious who has fought the better opposition

It's 7 belts in 7 weight classes for Manny actually :wave: i dont count ibo/nabf belts

even if floyd beats manny? manny has 5 belts in 5 weight classes floyd has 6 belts in 5 weight classes is this pure hate keeping floyd from being ranked higher in your eyes if he were to beat manny when they fight? It's 7 belts in 7 weight classes for Manny actually :wave: