Time to get Cotto out of the top ten P4P.

I think that Bradley and Dawson belong in the bottom half of the top ten now. I was skeptical about putting Dawson in there. But he erased the controversy of that first fight with Glen Johnson. And Bradley is taking on all comers at 140. I just wish he had more power.

After he beats Martinez he should get a bit more respect.

Paul belongs in there to me. Cotto getting drops makes sense to me too.

Williams is the definition of P4P, meaning he can go up and down weights beating the best in each. Only problem is nobody gives him the fights he's having to take whatever he can get.

He might be, he might not be. Williams really hasn't done anything to be ranked in the top 10. If he just whips up on Martinez then he could probably be in there. Honestly would not want to see Williams fight cotto, really would be a mismatch.

yup....Cotto is no where near P4P status these days.....he belongs on the sideline with JT.......these 2 dudes might get hurt if they continue to go on!!

One of the worst lists in years man. I am a fan of Donaire but he is so high on the list, #10 for him is even high enough.

Honestly though. Williams is a better fighter. Bully, Williams is a good fighter, but I just don't see any top WW fighting him. Maybe Cotto, but I really wouldn't want to see that.

Losing to the very best fighter shouldn't mean you get kicked out of the top 10. Exactly what's wrong with the sport. Losing a fight shouldn't make or break you in this sport. Honestly though. Williams is a better fighter.

Williams should be entering the list now. cosigned :Flush:

People say that Williams doesn't belong in the top 10 P4P, and that's just crazy. If anything, I think he should be in the top 4 because Mosley and Hopkins are the kings at taking year long layoffs. Mosley ducked Paul Williams to go after some overrated prospect who is a hype job to a lot of people. While Williams beat Mosley's conqueror, beat Margarito before Mosley got to him, and is fighting a better opponent than Berto. And Hopkins has for the fourth time, made a guy move up in weight. And don't even get me started on Floyd Mayweather. Please tell me why all these guys should be ranked over Paul Williams besides Manny Pacquiao.

He is at 7. Lost to a guy fighting for the second time at 147. Who happens to be the #1 fighter in the sport... And Paul hasn't done shit lately...

I think Cotto is still top ten p4p. Williams on the other hand is over-rated and would of got knocked out by Pavlik. My personal opinion btw. Don't hate.

Williams doesn't belong in the top 10.

I don't think so, Bully... Is this the official list? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_Magazine_pound_for_pound P. Will in the top 10..Cotto may drop some but I wouldn't drop him outta the list... He is at 7. Lost to a guy fighting for the second time at 147.

No....Cotto is still a top 10 IMO......Manny is just that good...

I don't think so, Bully... Is this the official list? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_Magazine_pound_for_pound P. Will in the top 10..Cotto may drop some but I wouldn't drop him outta the list...

its sad cause i also think that miguel will be removed from the top10 p4p :sad: