If Cotto took the same shots that dropped Hatton in the Floyd and Manny fights....

This man had an affair with Pacquiao, before he fought Ricky Hatton. http://acmevideo.files.wordpress.com/2009/06/david-carradine-grasshopper.jpg?w=313&h=485

Cotto has faced one guy at probably above Tzyu in Mosley (who was old) and allmost lost, his other 2 big fights he QUITS like a bitch and gets a robbery win at MSG. Cotto aint shit but he is too big for Pac, shame such a shit fighter will probably stop a great one in Pacman. Cotto beats the Tszyu that fought Hatton Hatton crumbles and gets KTFO by the Mosley that fought Cotto Hatton would get rocked and probably KO'd by Torres Hatton would have had a hard time with Corley..he even wobbled Mayweather!.. Hatton loses to Carlos Quintana, Antonio Margarito, and Joshua Clottey... there is NO COMPARING these 2.. Now you guys think I'm bashing Hatton..but I'm not..I like Hatton..I actually thought Hatton would beat Pacquiao and lost money on that one..but when you put him up against Cotto..he doesn't quite hold up..he was a good fighter with a great record and got exposed..

I agree..Cotto-Hatton would have been great at 140..but Cotto wins at 140 or 147 regardless.. and I still haven't gotten an answer on Hatton's quality of opposition..which guys would have HURT Cotto that weren't able to hurt Hatton?.. Cotto's chin is much sturdier than Hatton's PERIOD!.. None, seen as Cotto's chin is tested against big guys at WW like Mosley, Clottey and Margarito. He lost one of those fights and the other two where close fights which could have gone either way IMO.

Tszyu was P4P#2 when he fought Hatton. He weren't prime Tszyu but he wasn't shot either. Hatton has been hurt numerous times before Mayweather but he took the punishment and won. His chin wasn't class, he could take shots. Hatton's punch resistance left him after the Mayweathewr fight. The Collazo fight wasn't a robbery either. And i don't know why this thread has descended into who's better P4P? It was a question about chins. BTW, before you give it the old 'Biased Brit' shit, i think Cotto's better then Hatton P4P, but it's annoying that most of the Cotto fans on NSB talk about Hatton like he's a bum, while they think Cotto's the shit! Prime for prime, Hatton vs Cotto at 140 would have been a great fight and a toss up IMO. I agree..Cotto-Hatton would have been great at 140..but Cotto wins at 140 or 147 regardless.. and I still haven't gotten an answer on Hatton's quality of opposition..which guys would have HURT Cotto that weren't able to hurt Hatton?.. Cotto's chin is much sturdier than Hatton's PERIOD!.. Collazo fight a robbery. Come on man. It was a close fight that could have gone either way. If that was a robbery than Cotto Clottey must have been one as well. That KD was bullshit!..their feet got tangled right when Hatton was rushing him and Collazo stumbled and fell in the 1st.. Collazo had Hatton wobbled..and clinchin the whole round..could've easily been a 10-8 rd.. Hatton looked like shit..but he was there to show HBO something and failed..his 0 got protected there.. Cotto's 0 is gone..no need to protect that shit..Cotto jabbed Clottey cleanly and dropped him..to me and many others being the difference in the fight..if it wasn't for the KD it could have been a draw!.. Clottey would KO Hatton tho..but let's not even get in to that!..

Yes.. Prior to Mayweather and Pacquiao..Hatton fought Collazo..and was HURT!..he was on queer street and ready to be KO'd and Collazo was robbed.. Perro dude..you're a complete biased hater homie.. Name any decent opponent that Hatton had fought besides an old Kostya Tszyu.. Castillo was shot to shit! so name me the quality opponents that makes you so sure that Hatton's chin was this super duper GRANITE CHIN!.. Collazo fight a robbery. Come on man. It was a close fight that could have gone either way. If that was a robbery than Cotto Clottey must have been one as well.

That shot he landed on hatton would've knocked out Cotto at 147

Yes.. Prior to Mayweather and Pacquiao..Hatton fought Collazo..and was HURT!..he was on queer street and ready to be KO'd and Collazo was robbed.. Perro dude..you're a complete biased hater homie.. Name any decent opponent that Hatton had fought besides an old Kostya Tszyu.. Castillo was shot to shit! so name me the quality opponents that makes you so sure that Hatton's chin was this super duper GRANITE CHIN!.. Tszyu was P4P#2 when he fought Hatton. He weren't prime Tszyu but he wasn't shot either. Hatton has been hurt numerous times before Mayweather but he took the punishment and won. His chin wasn't class, he could take shots. Hatton's punch resistance left him after the Mayweathewr fight. The Collazo fight wasn't a robbery either. And i don't know why this thread has descended into who's better P4P? It was a question about chins. BTW, before you give it the old 'Biased Brit' shit, i think Cotto's better then Hatton P4P, but it's annoying that most of the Cotto fans on NSB talk about Hatton like he's a bum, while they think Cotto's the shit! Prime for prime, Hatton vs Cotto at 140 would have been a great fight and a toss up IMO.

Would you have said that prior to the Ricky vs Floyd fight? Really? When Cotto was seriously hurt by Torres, Corely, and running from Lovemore N'dou? Yes.. Prior to Mayweather and Pacquiao..Hatton fought Collazo..and was HURT!..he was on queer street and ready to be KO'd and Collazo was robbed.. Perro dude..you're a complete biased hater homie.. Name any decent opponent that Hatton had fought besides an old Kostya Tszyu.. Castillo was shot to shit! so name me the quality opponents that makes you so sure that Hatton's chin was this super duper GRANITE CHIN!..

Again my nigguh el Animalistico speaks the TRUTH!.. Cotto's chin shits on Hattons.. Cotto overall >>>>>>>>>Hatton 140 and 147..PERIOD only thing I ever seen decently special from Hatton was his body attack..beyond that..eh! Would you have said that prior to the Ricky vs Floyd fight? Really? When Cotto was seriously hurt by Torres, Corely, and running from Lovemore N'dou?

+1 And Collazo is not even a big puncher. Collazo also stunned Berto, which is a huge WW. Collazo is very underrated. he isn't elite, but he is the best second tier WW today.

You're funny. Prior to the Hatton vs Floyd fight, Ricky had never been hurt. Cotto had been HURT on several occasions. So, given this factual information, answer the fuckin' question. perra ... hatton had never been hurt? this is how i know you know shit about boxing and just ride messican cock. why don't you watch the magee fight for starters.

Seeing as how people underrate Hatton after Pacquiao destroyed him, I hope you guys don't do the same to Cotto after he probably loses badly to Pacquiao.

You're funny. Prior to the Hatton vs Floyd fight, Ricky had never been hurt. Cotto had been HURT on several occasions. So, given this factual information, answer the fuckin' question. Collazo had Hatton hurt in the later rounds.

Who the **** Hatton faced at 140 other than Kosta? I didn't see him facing Corley or Torres and you seem to forget that Cotto had problem making 140 for years so that had an effect on his chin. Hatton would have been KO by Torres if they ever faced eachother at 140. I can name one a bunch of guys in Cotto's resume that KO Hatton. Cotto's chin>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Hatton chin Not even a debate is needed. Again my nigguh el Animalistico speaks the TRUTH!.. Cotto's chin shits on Hattons.. Cotto overall >>>>>>>>>Hatton 140 and 147..PERIOD only thing I ever seen decently special from Hatton was his body attack..beyond that..eh!

Hatton used to be able to take a lot of punishment and still win, but after the Floyd fight, his punch resistance just seem to be gone. Prior to the Tszyu fight, Hatton was in wars with fighters he shouldn't have been in wars in. It caught up with him in the end.

Cotto has never been down by a punch in his life. In the Torres fight that was a push not a clean KD. Is not even debatable who has the best chin. Cotto's is way way way way wa way way way way better. You're funny. Prior to the Hatton vs Floyd fight, Ricky had never been hurt. Cotto had been HURT on several occasions. So, given this factual information, answer the fuckin' question.

Would there have been a similar outcome? Prior to watching Floyd vs Hatton and Manny vs Hatton, did you think that Hatton and Cotto's chins were comparable? Or did you think that maybe, just maybe, Ricky had a better chin than Miguel, who had previously been down at 140lbs. cotto should be able to walk through pac's best shots. pac don't hit harder than margo or mosley

i think cotto is more durable cotto was down at 140 when he was struggling to make weight. and hatton runs into punches with his chin up and unprotected even collazo stunned him

cotto's chin>>>>>>>>hatton's chin