Moore is no great shakes, but offers a relentless workrate with which JCC Jr would certainly struggle. (I'm actually a very big JCC Jr fan, although I readily admit he's long overdue for a test of any kind).
He fared well tonight, he just got caught by a punch from which he could never fully recover. If you saw the fight (or even read a review), you'd see that it wasn't as cut and dry as Rhodes TKO7 Moore.
I'd pick Moore to win a rematch, and I'd probably pick Chavez Jr to beat Rhodes.