Paul Williams vs Floyd Mayweather, at 147 who wins?

williams isn't the only fighter that has a chance against mayweather...i'd say shane with richardson in his corner is a very live dog...

pwill is too big agreed.... pwill is the only guy i think can beat pbf at 147....

Both come in at tip top shape and Williams makes the weight very comfortably. Vote and discuss. By the way, I think Williams wins a decisive UD. Lets settle the debate. pwill is too big

NOt to mention williams chin is solid as a rock lol this is ridiculous you guys are living in boxing fantasy land thinking that Floyd mayweather would beat Paul Williams. Castillo weight 9lbs heavier than FLoyd imagine Paul Williams coming in at 170lbs outweighing FLoyd by 12 lbs? Only fighters that would stand a chance would be Clottey Cotto and Mosley.

Williams UD12.

NOt to mention williams chin is solid as a rock

Both come in at tip top shape and Williams makes the weight very comfortably. Vote and discuss. By the way, I think Williams wins a decisive UD. Lets settle the debate. Where is Williams by devestating Knockout? If Mayweather in his peak prime had trouble with Castillo how the **** does he beat Williams. Castillo made Mayweather work, Imagine somebody like Williams with probably more pop and waaaay more skill and workrate. You guys give mayweather too much credit. The guy hasnt faced anybody dangerous whatsoever

Man Quintana boxed circles around that dude. Mayweather will see everything P Will throws Williams coming back and KO'ing Quintana in the 1st round of their rematch pretty much solidified he made mistakes in the 1st fight and corrected them. Trust me, Floyd will never fight him (especially if he takes Pavlik out).

Didnt Quintana leave Williams was cut over both eyes. He received nine and three stitches after the bout. Quintana outboxed P will with ease the first time. He landed more Total punches, jabs and power punches. Mayweather outboxes P Will. He also came back and KO'd Quintana in the 1st round...and is also fighting the Middleweight champ of the world. It's hard enough for Floyd to fight the WW champ of the world let alone beating Paul Williams. Floyd will never take that fight.

Floyd would make P Will hit air wit them long spider arms, as good as P Will looks we've yet to see him against a truly great fighter (Winky was an old ass rusty dude). I see Floyd keeping Williams turning and off balance while lookin to hit him with body shots from far before getting on the inside and smother the body all night those long arms would get nullified and wouldn't be able to catch Floyd wit any pop behind them.

Williams is too big. I know you guys love Floyd and believe he can even beat the Klitschko's, but P Will is simply a nightmare match up for Floyd.

Pwill outworks him to a UD. Too tall, too much reach, and too much activity for Mr boat buyer to handle. I agree...P-Will is one of those dudes that has the ability and gift to beat mayweather...BUT WE WILL NEVER KNOW

I think PBF wins this, Paul will be throwing alot but not landing much, kinda like when PBF fought the late Diego Corrales, Corrales couldnt find Floyd, and I dont think Pwill either, PBF by decesion. The reason why I say it will be like the Corrales fight is because of the height. naa i doubt it...corrales and williams are two different style fighters...

Mangler wins this fight just by turning on his tv.

Floyd would probably be favored, but Paul would be a live dog. Paul's the only fighter in the world who has a chance to beat Floyd. And Floyd's the only fighter in the world who has a chance to Paul now that he's starting to reach the peak of his talent. I dont know im not convinced with Pwill yet, he looks good and has a nice win over Margarito, and came back againts that loss to Quintana, the win againts Winky..ahh..dont know..he was past him prime. Until I see him fight 1 of the top fighters out there I wont be convinced. And again Pwill has not fought anyone that comes close to PBF in boxing ability.

Floyd would probably be favored, but Paul would be a live dog. Paul's the only fighter in the world who has a chance to beat Floyd. And Floyd's the only fighter in the world who has a chance to Paul now that he's starting to reach the peak of his talent.

I still say it will be like PBF vs Corrales, Pwill has not faced anyone with 1/2 the boxing ability and movement of PBF. How is Pwill suppose to beat PBF?..Floyd isnt going to stand there in front of him, like Winky, Margarito etc..Now im no Floyd nut hugger but I look at things for what they are FLoyd is the most talented boxer out there from 147-160. Pwill will look like an amateur he dont have the foot work or skill to hang with Floyd.

Part of me thinks Williams would just outhustle his ass round after round after round. Too big, too long, and too much stamina. But then I see what the smaller Quintana was able to do to Paul in their first fight by schooling him the way he did.....And Carlos isn't one tenth of the fighter Floyd is, so why not? It'll never happen though.

I give Paul a very good chance but if Floyd takes away his workrate he's shit... Paul isn't difficult to hit either... I think Floyd can devise a gameplan to beat P. Will. Paul's been beaten before... Anyone who thinks Paul would beat the shit outta Floyd or vice versa is retarded...

First if your on top and are fighting proven fighters you shouldn't be the first fight a guy a'la mayweather and williams so the whole dodging williams thing holds no water IMO everybody avoided him but floyd is the only one accountable?... and to the question I think floyd would win a decision because with the right tools and know-how you can break down that long build by staying in the pocket which i've seen floyd do in many fights with greater efficiency than at least every active fighter. and floyd's as slick if not slicker than quintana with twice the hand speed. and with his reflexes and timing he should be able to close the gap on paul very often