Who has a bigger claim to beating Cotto, Mosley or Clottey?

The scorecard was definitely ridiculous....114 113 I had it for Cotto.

That rabbit punch was all an act and was accidental and Clottey was holding onto his arm for dear life. I'm not even a Cotto fan, I'm just getting tired of all this bull shit. He lost the fight...fight Berto, Williams...somebody and he'll get another shot. I think Clottey should go after Berto. Either that or take on a Carlos Quintana and beat some names to get to the top again. He has options: Collazo Quintana Margarito Pwill all those are decent names.. he can be champ again.

That rabbit punch was all an act and was accidental and Clottey was holding onto his arm for dear life. I'm not even a Cotto fan, I'm just getting tired of all this bull shit. He lost the fight...fight Berto, Williams...somebody and he'll get another shot. Im just saying. The guy was making excuses for the cut. So, I baught up the fouls that cotto did that can hinder a fighter. Im okay with Cotto winning, but the score card was just rediculous.

Clottey was love-tapped on the balls, rabbit punched, and body slammed. Should we take that away from Cotto's win? That rabbit punch was all an act and was accidental and Clottey was holding onto his arm for dear life. I'm not even a Cotto fan, I'm just getting tired of all this bull shit. He lost the fight...fight Berto, Williams...somebody and he'll get another shot.

Cotto beat them both in close but clear decisions. The closer more competitive fight was with Clottey though.

Clottey's fight was closer but he still lost,wherew is the neither option in this poll,this poll is garbage

Clottey. That fight would have been a clear draw with the exception of the 1st round knockdown. I wasn't convinced of the win by Cotto, but was content with the SD, as it showed that the fight could have gone either way. Mosley got outboxed clearly.

like cotto didn't have blood pouring into his eye for the whole fight, your nothing but a hater. Clottey was love-tapped on the balls, rabbit punched, and body slammed. Should we take that away from Cotto's win?

Clottey was closer. I had Cotto-Clottey a draw with the point giving Cotto the win. I had Mosley losing 7-5.

Clottey has a better claim. He faught a closer fight. The 10-8 round was what did him in.

Cotto ran from both of them. Clottey beat him rather easily, despite having to chase the runner around with an injury. like cotto didn't have blood pouring into his eye for the whole fight, your nothing but a hater.

Nothing...the whining Clottey gave that shit away. Instead of acting trying to get points for fouls...he should of just whooped that ass like he was doing for rounds 7-10

clottey by far. half way through the fight cotto turned into Lance Armstrong and hopped on his bicycle

Clottey was much closer... I was at MSG for Cotto Mosley... was the ONLY person in th estadium rooting for mosley LOL I felt Cotto def won it.. Gee, I wonder why you were rooting for Mosley...... ;)

I believe cotto won both fights on the scorecards clottey gave him a harder time, cotto was more physically damaged in this fight. With mosley, I thought shane looked a little beaten up at the end of the fight, so in simple terms I thought clottey lost on the cards but he inflicted more damage to cotto, but cotto inflicted more damage on shane and won more rounds...both close though

So Mosley was plastered now? i thought it said marg and clottey. my mistake.

Cotto ran from both of them. Clottey beat him rather easily, despite having to chase the runner around with an injury. you just lost all credibilty with that statement. you can argue clottey won a close dec but won easily come on you just exposed yourself as a hater.

I've got Cotto winning both fights. Clottey seemed a lot closer but I'm not sure how much of that is credited to the gash and the drama.

Clottey cuz he didnt use plaster So Mosley was plastered now?

Clottey cuz he didnt use plaster