..Out Of All The Active Fighters...

While everything you say is technically true, I've scored both fights for Marquez. Not that my scorecard counts, but the fact remains that A LOT of people picked Marquez as the victor in both fights. Regardless, Marquez still fought him. That adds to his list. You don't have to beat a guy, to have fought a guy, obviously. yout dont have to beat the guy, but it's better if you win. You could fight a lot of top fighters and lose to most *DLH* and still be considered great. But you shouldn't be as great as somebody who beats every or most top fighter he faces *Pacquiao, Hopkins, Mosley, etc.*

JMM got dropped 4 times by Pacquiao, and the first fight got dropped 3 times in the first round, which makes it a 10-6 round, so he shouldn't have won the first and Got KD again in the second which is a FACTOR in a close fight, if you didn't know because that makes a 10-8 round. While everything you say is technically true, I've scored both fights for Marquez. Not that my scorecard counts, but the fact remains that A LOT of people picked Marquez as the victor in both fights. Regardless, Marquez still fought him. That adds to his list. You don't have to beat a guy, to have fought a guy, obviously. But it doesn't answer my original question.

JMM beat Pac twice, Casamayor, Barrera, and Morales always avoided him so you could also count him. JMM by landslide. Oh yeah and he's about to beat Mayweather too. If you had any serious points, I'd bet you in a heartbeat.

JMM beat Pac twice, Casamayor, Barrera, and Morales always avoided him so you could also count him. JMM by landslide. Oh yeah and he's about to beat Mayweather too. JMM got dropped 4 times by Pacquiao, and the first fight got dropped 3 times in the first round, which makes it a 10-6 round, so he shouldn't have won the first and Got KD again in the second which is a FACTOR in a close fight, if you didn't know because that makes a 10-8 round.

Yeah, for the record, I left out fighters that I thought stand little chance to adding to this particular list. Meaning, Jones and Holyfiend wouldn't make that list. Regardless of who they face, it's unlikely that it's a HOFer. Hector Camacho would also apply. Oddly enough, one could make the claim that Antonio Tarver has a noteworthy list himself. He didn't beat Bernard, but he's still got two HOFers on the list.

Out of that list, I think it's Pacquiao. Morales x2, Marquez, Barrera x2, DLH, Hatton (borderline).

but iguess so technically Evander has fought more HOFers

Holy's still listed active on BoxRec so I guess it's him... I got a funny feeling he'll get a rematch w/ the yeti since the promoter for the Chag-Valuev re-match is Sauerland, HIS promoter so don't be surprised if he gets the decision and bypasses the mandatory Ruiz III :ugh: to get a rematch w/ Holy

well Hector Camacho is about to fight again and Tommy Hearns is talking about fighting again that doesnt meant anything. Evander HOPEFULLY wont be remembered by the embarressement he is doing to himself now

Evander, RJJ, and B-Hop all could make claims then Pacquiao...

Roy Jones Jr. Mike Mccallum, Bhop, James Toney, Virgil Hill, possibly Antonio Tarver.... 4 guarentees possible 5th B-Hop has Tito, Oscar, possibly Winky, Tarver, and maybe Pavlik if he reigns longer in MW.

Evander jus fought in December like it or not...and maybe RJJ if u would put Tarver or McCallum in...

Floyd has 1 (oscar) Hopkins has 2 (oscar and tito) Mrquez has 1/2 (old barrera) Pacman has 3 1/2 (barrera, marquez, morales and old oscar Floyd has an OLD oscar to who was just one year older when he fought Pacqiuao. i think Hatton has a chance of making the HOF because he was global, had a FANTASTIC FAN BASE, and beat some good fighters in 140. Im not saying he is a ATG but he could possibly make the HOF.

Floyd has 1 (oscar) Hopkins has 2 (oscar and tito) Mrquez has 1/2 (old barrera) Pacman has 3 1/2 (barrera, marquez, morales and old oscar Roy Jones Jr. Mike Mccallum, Bhop, James Toney, Virgil Hill, possibly Antonio Tarver.... 4 guarentees possible 5th

yeah Evander but does he really count right now?

Evander Holyfield... Mike Tyson, Larry Holmes, George Foreman Riddick Bowe could get in along with Moorer... Up next would be Pacquiao Technically Holyfield could make the claim. But.......... I just don't think he should be fighting anymore. Active, I agree. So, you're right but..........

Evander Holyfield... Mike Tyson, Larry Holmes, George Foreman Riddick Bowe could get in along with Moorer... Up next would be Pacquiao

Floyd has 1 (oscar) Hopkins has 2 (oscar and tito) Mrquez has 1/2 (old barrera) Pacman has 3 1/2 (barrera, marquez, morales and old oscar