If Hatton walks away is he a Hall of Famer?

He might get in. He pretty much lived off of that Tszyu win his whole career. Although it's a great win, is it one of those that gets you into the Hall? I dont think it should be, but it might. Tszyu was also older and inactive.

He can hold the door for Pac and Floyd...that's as far as he goes.

Not in my book but he could get in...regardless a good fighter with some nice wins but not a great.

Possibly but their will always be questions over him after being knocked out brutally in his 2 biggest fights by prime top p4p fighters...

There are less deserving memebers in there already so he'll probably get in.